Chapter 7: The Third Set
The dehumidifier had a full tank. Tobias lifted it from the machine and carried it carefully past Helen, who held the archive door open with her foot.
“Where does it go?” he asked.
The archivist pointed towards a sink at the end of the corridor. “If you’re offering.”
While he was gone, Helen opened the first box. Its lid had been labelled Commissioning: acoustic in blue felt-tip. Inside were folders tied with cotton tape, a rolled drawing and a packet of photographs. The top photograph showed the empty auditorium before the seats were installed. Dust lay across the concrete floor, and a work light stood where the centre aisle would be.
Tobias returned, drying his hands on his trousers. “The archivist says the lift drawings may be in another store. She’s checking.”
Helen passed him the photograph. He studied it briefly, then set it beside the box.
“I found a reference to three measurement sets in the index,” he said. “September, October and November. The issued report only gives two sets of results.”
“There may have been a repeat that wasn’t usable.”
“It’s possible.”
He untied the first folder. The papers inside were ordered by date, with coloured tabs along the edges. Helen recognised Duncan’s handwriting on several: large, upright letters that became cramped whenever he reached the right-hand margin.
The September sheets listed positions and equipment. The November folder held the figures she knew from the report. Between them was a thinner file, its cover marked October—supplementary.
Tobias opened it. “There’s no results table.”
“Look for the field notes.”
He found a typed sheet, a floor plan with crosses on it and a draft section of the report. Helen drew the draft towards her. Her own handwriting ran between the typed lines, smaller than Duncan’s and sloping uphill.
She read the first page, then turned back to the beginning.
“You wrote the section?” Tobias asked.
Helen turned the page towards him.
At the foot of a table she had circled the difference between the predicted and measured decay. Beside it she had written: Array—greater contribution than modelled? On the next page the question had become a sentence: The enhanced late response is attributable to the diffuser array.
Duncan had pencilled a vertical line beside it.
“Is that his?” Tobias asked.
“It looks like his pencil.”
“Does it mean he disagreed?”
“He used a line for things he wanted to discuss. Sometimes it meant he wanted a comma.” Helen held the page closer. “Here, he’s put ‘basis?’”
Tobias leaned over the table. “Did you have measurements from the panel tests by then?”
“Scattering measurements, yes. The prototype and the installed arrangement both performed well.” She touched the sentence with a fingertip. “We knew the array was doing something useful.”
“But not how much it contributed to the longer decay.”
“We had a model and commissioning results. The results were better than predicted.”
“Could the array have accounted for the low-frequency difference?”
Helen looked at the table. She had asked herself the same question in her office, with the red report open beside Tobias’s calculation. Seeing the draft brought back the pressure of finishing it: the figures arriving late, Duncan asking for a section he could take to the client, the satisfaction of putting a sentence where the blank had been.
“It was a hypothesis,” she said.
Tobias waited.
“I mean, that’s how it began. We had an effect the model hadn’t predicted, and the array was a significant difference between the model and the room.”
“Was it the only difference?”
She turned another page. “There were the usual construction tolerances. Changes in materials and fittings. We checked what we could.”
“And the low frequencies?”
She took her finger away from the paper. “The scattering results supported what we said about the array. They didn’t establish that it explained all of this.”
Tobias nodded, but he did not reach for the draft. Helen heard the dehumidifier start again, its motor settling into a steady hum.
“Can I photograph those pages?” he asked.
“Include the table and Duncan’s annotations.”
He took out his phone. Helen held the pages flat while he worked, moving her hand when its shadow crossed the print. On the last sheet a paperclip had left a rust-coloured mark. Tobias eased it off and found a folded note underneath.
The paper had been torn from a pad. On one side Duncan had listed three dates and what looked like equipment numbers. On the other he had written:
Stage void? Investigate before final attribution. Check with HB.
Tobias looked up. “That’s you?”
“Helen Broughton, then. I used my mother’s surname professionally before I married Gil.”
She read the note again. Duncan had put a question mark after void, not after the instruction to investigate. She could remember him at his desk, his shirtsleeves rolled unevenly, asking for the figures. She could not place this scrap in his hand or hear what either of them had said about it.
“Did he ask you?” Tobias said.
“He may have done. I don’t remember.”
The words sounded evasive even to her. Tobias held the note by its corners, waiting for more.
“I remember discussions about the report,” she said. “Not this one. We need to see whether there’s anything in the correspondence.”
He put the note beside the draft and photographed both sides. Helen checked the rest of the folder: a receipt for hired equipment, two pages of handwritten levels and an envelope with no contents. Nothing recorded an investigation of the space behind the stage.
Tobias opened the box again and reached beneath the rolled drawing. “There’s a case here.”
It was a small plastic cassette case, clouded with scratches. The label on its spine read Meridian Oct 94, with Duncan’s initials and the number three. Inside was a DAT cassette, its handwritten label matching the case.
Tobias did not take it out. “That might be the supplementary set.”
“Might.”
“There’s a machine at the university archive. I can ask them about a transfer.”
Helen looked at the cassette through the clear lid. The tape could contain a failed test, a few minutes of voices, or something Duncan had wanted them to hear. She wanted to know which before it passed into another person’s hands.
“Let’s check its condition first,” she said. “And what the archive requires.”
The archivist came back with a trolley and an apologetic expression. The lift drawings, she said, were listed under the contractor’s project number; she had requested the box from the off-site store. It would take a few days.
Tobias closed the cassette case. “Could we leave this with you while we arrange a transfer?”
“Of course. I’ll log it separately.”
Helen watched the archivist write the accession reference on a slip of paper. Tobias gave her the folder and its box number, then added the dates from Duncan’s note. He was thorough without making a display of it. Helen had valued that in him from the beginning.
The archive bar was closed between performances, but the archivist had said they could use a table there. Tobias brought two paper cups from the machine in the corridor. Helen put hers down and immediately picked it up again; the table was cold through the thin cup.
Tobias sat opposite her with his notebook open. “I’ll contact the university this afternoon. They’ll want the format and whatever we know about storage.”
“Ask what they can do, but don’t send it yet.”
He looked up. “Why?”
“I’d like to hear the transfer before it circulates.”
“They’d give us a file. I wasn’t suggesting putting it online.”
“I know. But once a transfer goes into an institutional archive, there may be other access conditions. Find out what they are.”
Tobias turned his pen between his fingers. “The tape belongs to the Meridian. Shouldn’t the archivist decide where the file goes?”
“She should know what’s proposed. I’m asking you to establish the options first.”
“And if there’s something on it that changes the report?”
Helen pulled the lid from her cup. The coffee smelled burnt. “Then we’ll need to understand it.”
“Together?”
She met his eyes. “Together.”
He wrote something in his notebook. Helen could not see the words from her side of the table.
“I don’t want the tape played repeatedly on an old machine,” he said. “If it’s damaged, an archivist needs to assess it. And there should be a raw transfer, before anyone processes it.”
“I agree.”
“I’ll make a record of where it came from and who handles it.”
“All right,” Helen said.
He continued writing. When he had finished, he turned the notebook slightly towards her. He had dated the entry and listed the box, folder and cassette label. Beneath those he had written: Helen requested that transfer not be circulated before we have heard it. Confirm access arrangements with Meridian.
She felt the impulse to correct the sentence.
“That makes it sound as though I’m trying to keep it from them.”
“Is that what you’re trying to do?”
“I don’t want an incomplete recording treated as a result before we know what it is.”
He considered her, then added: Reason given: establish content and transfer conditions first.
“That’s fair,” he said.
Helen could have asked him to remove the entry. Instead she drank the coffee. It was worse than it smelled.
Tobias closed his notebook. “Three sets,” he said. “If this is the October one, we may be able to match it to the dates on the note.”
“Provided the label is right. And provided it still plays.”
“I’ll ask the archivist to keep the case and label with it.”
From somewhere above them came a brief scrape of chairs, then a door closing. Helen thought of the line in Duncan’s hand: Investigate before final attribution. She had no memory of seeing it. She could not yet tell whether that made any difference.
“Send me the contact details when you have them,” she said.
Tobias put his notebook in his bag. “I’ll copy you on the message.”