Chapter 2: Tolerances
By nine, the windows of Ardith & Pryce had lost their view of the river. Rain pressed against the glass, turning the opposite bank into a strip of blurred brick.
Helen stood outside Dominic’s office with two coffees. She had bought them on the way upstairs because she needed him to listen before his first meeting. One had leaked through its lid onto her thumb.
Dominic opened the door himself. “You were there all night?”
“Until four.”
“You should have called me.”
“At four?”
“I’d have been asleep, but you could have left a message.”
He took a cup and moved a pile of papers from the chair opposite his desk. His office occupied a corner of the converted warehouse, with exposed ductwork overhead and a long window looking downriver. The duct had been painted the same muted grey as the walls. Helen had once remarked that it would be easier to clean if it were enclosed. Dominic had said that would defeat the purpose.
She put her notebook on the desk and turned it toward him.
“We repeated the measurements. They’re consistent with each other, but the old report doesn’t give us enough to make a confident comparison yet.”
He looked at the page. “The figures are lower.”
“At these positions, with the hall empty, they’re lower than the commissioning figures. We need the original records before we say how much has changed.”
“And the orchestra?”
“They’ve been reporting a problem. I’d like to talk to Nadia Corr before we go any further.”
Dominic set down his coffee. “Beatrix mentioned your name when we spoke last week. She said the trustees would be glad to have you involved.”
Helen had expected that. Her name was still useful to the firm in ways that could not be entered neatly on a timesheet. When she sold Sarkis Acoustics to Ardith & Pryce in 2019, she had imagined the relief of no longer managing a practice: no leases, no salary negotiations, no evenings spent working out which invoice could wait. She now worked three days a week as a consulting principal. Dominic occasionally asked her to do four, presenting the request as though he had only just thought of it.
“The Trust asked us to investigate,” she said. “That’s separate from the restoration bid.”
“For the moment.”
“It ought to stay separate until they know what they need.”
Dominic leaned back. “Helen, they have an anniversary appeal to launch and a building full of people saying the sound has changed. They’ll need a team who can tell them what’s possible.”
“I can’t promise them the old sound.”
“I’m not asking for that.”
“You will be asked. And if you answer before we understand the problem, they’ll remember the answer.”
His phone lit up. He glanced at it, turned it face down and gave her his attention again.
“We lost the university job on Friday,” he said. “It was going to keep three people busy through the summer. I’m trying to find work for them.”
“I know. I saw the email.”
“Then you know why I’m interested.”
She did. She also knew the people he meant: one had a new baby, another had been looking for a flat, and the third had recently turned down a job elsewhere after Dominic assured her there was plenty coming in.
“I’m interested too,” Helen said. “But a lower number isn’t a diagnosis.”
“It’s a reason to look.”
He took a sip and made a face at the coffee. “Give me the version I can tell Beatrix without having to ring you afterwards and apologise.”
“Tell her the initial readings merit investigation. Tell her we’re checking the historical records and speaking to the orchestra. Don’t tell her we can restore anything.”
“I can tell her that.”
“And the Trust needs to know we’re considering a bid.”
“Beatrix already knows we’re interested.”
“I’d like it recorded.”
He nodded, a fraction more slowly this time. “I’ll put it in the letter.”
Helen closed her notebook. She had come prepared to argue longer, and his agreement left her momentarily unsure what to do with her hands.
Dominic opened his diary. “How much of Tobias’s time?”
“Two days this week, if he’s available.”
“He’s on the Belgrave school.”
“He was with me last night. He knows the measurements.”
“And he’ll be asleep at his desk by lunchtime.”
“So will I.”
“I’m less worried about you making a mistake with the fees.” He checked the screen again. “I can move the school visit to Thursday. You can have him until then.”
“We may need longer.”
“Ask me when you know.” He tapped a date. “The Trust’s outline brief is due in three weeks. Can you give me something by next Friday? Findings, uncertainties, what you propose doing next. No promises.”
“That depends on the records.”
“Give me a page about the records, then.”
He said it lightly, but he left the date visible on the screen. Helen knew what a page could become once it had passed through enough hands. Still, she needed Tobias, and Dominic had given him to her.
At the door he said, “Beatrix is proud of that hall. She told me she first heard an orchestra there with her father.”
Helen looked back.
“She didn’t say whose orchestra?”
“She did. I’ve forgotten.” He smiled. “I thought the father was the important part.”
Outside, Tobias was standing by the printer, holding a sheet as if he had forgotten why he had printed it. His hair was still damp from the rain.
“You should go home,” Helen said.
“I’ve only just got here.”
“You should have gone home, then.”
“I did. I wanted to make sure the files were on the server.” He held up the sheet. “I’ve listed the positions we need to check against the old records.”
She took it. He had noted the missing source specifications and marked two receiver locations with question marks.
“Dominic’s given you the next two days,” she said.
Tobias looked pleased, then tried to hide it. “For the Meridian?”
“For finding out whether we can trust what we think we found at the Meridian.”
“That’s better than the Belgrave school.”
“Don’t say that near the education team.”
“I wouldn’t. They know I want their job.”
He went back to the printer for a second page. “There’s something else. I did a calculation on the Meridian for my dissertation draft.”
He showed her a footnote questioning whether the array could account for the low-frequency excess. He had compared the published figures with a simplified estimate, but could not say what else might have produced the response.
“You’re comparing unlike things,” Helen said. “Unless you can offer another mechanism, I’d leave the footnote out.”
He folded the page. “I thought the uncertainty was worth mentioning.”
“The dissertation has enough to do already.” She handed it back. He stapled the measurement sheets together, and Helen hoped he would get some sleep before he began.
By evening the office had emptied around her. The ventilation continued at its steady low rate, and somewhere along the corridor a loose blind tapped against a window frame.
The commissioning report lay open beside Helen’s laptop. Its red binding had faded to a colour closer to brown at the spine. She had brought this copy from home years ago, after a client asked about the Meridian, and it had remained on her shelf at Ardith & Pryce. There were pencil marks in the margins, some hers, some she could no longer place.
Duncan’s signature was on the final page. He had been the senior partner responsible for the commission; Helen had drafted much of the report, carrying pages into his office for comment and taking them away again. She remembered him removing whole sentences with a single line and then asking, mildly, whether she had wanted to keep them.
The issued account attributed the hall’s favourable response in large part to the diffuser array. She read the paragraph twice, then turned back to the table of predicted values.
The array had worked. Its panels had been tested, their scattering performance documented. She could still picture the drawings, the patient negotiation over dimensions, the fabricator’s hands turning the first section to show her a joint. None of that was in doubt.
But the measured low-frequency decay had exceeded the prediction by more than the report’s explanation seemed to cover.
Helen took a pencil and wrote the difference beside the table. She checked her subtraction, annoyed at herself for checking it, then went to the appendix for the measurement conditions. The source positions were there, though one was described by reference to a drawing not included in this copy. The receiver coordinates were listed; the equipment information was less complete than she wanted.
Her phone lit up beside the report.
Roz calling.
Helen let it ring while she finished copying a figure. Roz usually sent a message first. Helen reached for the phone, saw the column she had not yet checked and decided to call back in a minute. The ringing stopped.
She compared the table with Tobias’s preliminary figures. The 500-hertz difference was around two-tenths, as they had seen in the hall; the average covered several bands and needed the underlying values checked before she used it outside the office. She made a note to ask Tobias to locate the original test sheets.
The phone lit again, this time with a message.
Can you call? It’s about Grandad.
Helen looked at the clock. Nearly seven. At Wray Court, supper would be over. Roz might have visited after work and found Arto tired, or found his laundry missing again, or been given another form to complete. Helen picked up the phone and pressed her daughter’s name.
There was no answer. She tried once more, then left a message.
“Roz, it’s me. I’m sorry, I was in the middle of something. Call when you can. I’m still at the office, but I’ll have my phone.”
She kept it beside the laptop as she turned back to the report. Five minutes later she found herself rereading the same sentence. She sent a text asking whether Arto was all right.
Roz replied almost at once.
He’s fine tonight. I needed you to speak to the manager before she left. I’ve dealt with it.
Helen typed What was it? and waited. The three dots appeared, vanished, then appeared again.
I’ll tell you tomorrow.
She put the phone down. There was a faint ring of coffee on the cover of the report where she had set her cup. She rubbed it with her thumb; the mark spread and stayed.
The paragraph on the array ended with a sentence she recognised as her own. She had liked its economy when she wrote it. It moved from the measured result to the explanation in a single assured step.
Helen drew a small line beside it in the margin. Then she opened a fresh page in her notebook and wrote: What else could account for the low-frequency excess?
She left space beneath the question.