Chapter 4: Value Engineering
October 1993
The heater in the site cabin smelled of paraffin and damp wool. Helen had taken off her coat but kept it over her knees, because the draught came up through the floor.
Eleven men sat or stood around the table. Rain had curled the edges of the drawings, and someone had put an ashtray on the corner of the section through the stage. Helen moved it before the paper tore.
“We can line the lot flat,” the contractor said. “Same board throughout. That’s the saving.”
He had written the figure in thick pencil on the back of an envelope. The project manager passed it to Helen.
“And the ribs?” she asked.
“Gone.”
“They’re part of the acoustic design.”
“They’re part of the cost.”
There was a little movement around the table: men looking down, one reaching for a biscuit. Helen was twenty-eight and had been in enough meetings to recognise the pause in which everyone waited for her to become difficult.
She laid her pencil across the drawing. “A flat surface gives us strong reflections in directions we don’t want. The ribs break those up.”
The contractor folded his arms. “We’ve built concert halls before.”
“Then you know why the surfaces aren’t all flat.”
Duncan, at the far end of the table, turned a page without looking up. He had told her on the train that morning to defend what mattered and let the rest go. He had not said how she was to distinguish the two while twelve people watched.
The project manager tapped the envelope. “We need a number, Helen. Not a lecture on reflections.”
She felt the heat in her face. “I haven’t given you one.”
“You’re about to.”
A few of them laughed, including Duncan. Helen looked at him. His expression changed, but he said nothing.
She pulled the section towards her. The original design used separately formed elements, each set at a slightly different angle. The fabricator had priced every one as a separate operation.
“What if the variation is in the face rather than the structure?” she said.
The architect leaned closer. “How?”
“Repeated backing frames. A limited set of face profiles fixed to them.” She drew three quick shapes on the margin: shallow, deeper, asymmetric. “You’d get repetition in the fabrication without presenting the same surface at every point.”
The contractor took her pencil. “You’d still have all these cuts.”
“Fewer than now.”
“Depends what you make them from.”
“Gypsum on a composite frame, perhaps. We’d need to test it.”
He drew a thicker line through one of her profiles. “And this edge will chip before we get it on a lorry.”
“Then make the edge return.”
“That adds a joint.”
Helen held out her hand for the pencil. He gave it back. Together, without quite looking at one another, they worked over the corner of the drawing while the project manager waited.
The architect said, “Could the joints be expressed? Instead of trying to make the whole thing look seamless?”
“If the spacing works,” Helen said.
The contractor leaned back. “I’ll get a price for a prototype. I’m not promising your saving.”
“I’m not asking you to.”
“You were a minute ago.”
“I was asking you not to flatten the stage.”
The project manager took the drawing and examined the sketches. “Develop it, then. But I want the cost against the present design, and I want the structural engineer to see it before anyone orders a mould.”
Helen wrote prototype in her notebook. Her hand was unsteady, though she did not think anyone had noticed. Across the table Duncan gave her a small nod. She wanted him to say, in front of the others, that it was her proposal. He asked instead whether the new arrangement would fit within the shell depth.
“It should,” she said. “Subject to the frame and fixings.”
“Check it.”
Helen made a note beside the sketch.
The meeting moved on to door ironmongery. Helen sat with her coat over her knees and drew the three profiles again, more carefully. Outside, a lorry reversed through the rain with a slow electronic warning. She thought of Roz at the nursery, asleep perhaps, one hand under her cheek. Gil was collecting her at six.
Helen looked at her watch. There was time to catch the early train if the meeting ended when it was supposed to.
At five forty, the project manager asked them to stay for the revised programme.
The phone in the site office took coins, and Helen had only enough for a short call. She held the receiver tight against her ear while traffic passed on the road beyond the hoarding.
Gil answered on the fourth ring. She heard Roz making a high, insistent sound behind him.
“I’m still at the site,” Helen said. “The meeting ran over.”
“I worked that out from the time.”
“I’ll get the next train.”
“Which next train?”
She checked the timetable she had folded into her notebook. “Seven twelve.”
A pause. Something rattled at his end.
“Sorry,” he said. “She’s found the saucepan cupboard. Seven twelve gets you in at eight?”
“Eight oh six. Gil, I think we’ve saved it.”
“Saved what?”
“The stage treatment. They wanted to take the ribs out and put up flat board. I’ve got them looking at a different construction.”
“Hang on.” The clatter stopped, followed by a small protest from Roz. “Right. Tell me.”
Helen leaned against the wall of the office and described the repeated frames, the different faces, the saving in labour if the fabricator could make the profiles work. Gil asked how the panels would be fixed and whether the architect would tolerate visible joints.
“He suggested them.”
“Then you’ve had a very good day.”
“It feels like it.”
She could hear him smiling. He had been the one to mention her to the Meridian architect when the acoustics appointment was being discussed. He had come home from a practice dinner and written a name and number on the back of a receipt.
Call him tomorrow. Don’t wait for me to arrange it.
She had called. After the interview, she had asked Gil whether he had told them they ought to hire her.
“I said you’d be cross if I did,” he had replied.
Now Roz let out a cry, closer to the telephone.
“She’s tired,” Gil said. “I’ve tried the pasta, but most of it’s on the floor.”
“I can give her a bath when I get back.”
“She’ll be in bed.”
“I could come up and see her.”
“You can do that.”
Helen watched the second hand move around the office clock. “I’m sorry. I thought I’d make the earlier one.”
“I know.” He lowered his voice, though Roz was still vocal beside him. “There’s milk on your side of the bed, by the way. She got hold of her cup this morning. I changed the sheet, but I couldn’t turn the mattress on my own.”
“I’ll do it when I get in.”
“You’ll wake her.”
“Then tomorrow.”
“Tomorrow, then.”
There was another clatter, and Gil said, “No, that’s the lid,” away from the receiver. Helen smiled despite herself.
“Tell her I’ll see her in the morning.”
“She’s thirteen months old, Helen. I’ll tell her, but don’t count on a useful reply.”
When the line went dead, Helen stayed where she was for a moment. She wanted to call him back and make him understand how close they had come to losing the design. Instead she put her notebook in her bag and went out to catch the train.
In January she travelled to the fabrication works to see the first panel. A man in a blue overall led her across a concrete floor scattered with pale dust. The panel stood upright in a timber jig, its face divided into the shallow irregular planes she had drawn in the cabin.
“It’s heavier than we hoped,” he said. “We’ve changed the backing.”
Helen put her palm against it. The gypsum was cold, the corner neatly returned where the contractor had said it would chip.
“Can you make the next one with the deeper profile?”
“We’ve already started. You’ll need to sign off the fixing detail before we make the batch.”
She crouched to look at the lower joint. A pencil mark showed where the frame sat behind the face. It was a physical thing now, with weight and edges and a flaw near one corner where the surface had caught as it came out of the mould.
The fabricator touched the flaw with a thumbnail. “We’ll fill that.”
“Leave it for the test.”
He raised his eyebrows.
“I want to know what ordinary production looks like.”
He found a clean patch on the bench for the drawings. Helen took off her gloves and went through the fixing detail with him, asking for a section at the joint and another sample of the finish. By the time she came out, her train had gone.
She used the station phone to tell Gil she would be late. He asked whether the panel was any good.
“It’s good,” she said. “There are things to change, but it’s good.”
“That’s worth missing a train for.”
She accepted the comfort of it. On the journey home she opened her notebook and began a list for the next visit. At the top she wrote fixings, then underlined it twice.