Chapter 13 of 35

AI-generated book by Adrian KnoxBook rights and permissions

Chapter 10: A Classification

Dov found the schedule in a drawer that stuck when the tide was high.

He pulled it out with both hands, setting the loose paperweight on the floor before the drawer could tip. Inside were maintenance diagrams, a ferry timetable and a sheet of brittle laminate folded around a pencil.

The pencil had left a gray line down the center of the sheet. Dov opened it carefully on the bench.

MUNICIPAL SERVICE CLASSIFICATIONS, 2036–37.

He ran a finger down the narrow columns until he reached 44.

Priority cardiac assessment.

A note in his own handwriting pointed to a separate schedule of funded places. He had written it years ago, when he was trying to make sense of the numbers printed on old notices. The pencil had bitten through the laminate.

The doorbell struck the glass. Noor came in carrying a paper bag darkened by rain.

“I bought breakfast,” she said.

“You found the place on the corner?”

“It was the only one open.”

“That answers my next question.”

She put the bag on the bench. Dov moved the schedule away from the spreading grease before taking out a flatbread.

“Class forty-four,” he said.

Noor leaned over the sheet. Her hair was damp at the temples. She read the entry, then the heading, then turned the page over as if the answer might continue there.

“Priority cardiac assessment,” she said. “That matches Delia’s service.”

“It matches the name, anyway.”

“And the number.”

“Both can be copied.”

She looked up. “You think it’s a coincidence?”

“I think whoever built the current list might have started with the old one. Or they might have kept the number because people were used to it.” He pointed at the date. “This tells us what it meant thirteen years ago.”

Noor took her notebook from her bag and wrote down the heading and publication year. “Does the schedule show a ceiling?”

“Not this sheet. I’ve got a plan that does.”

“For forty-four?”

“Yes. An old plan for Northreach.”

She paused with her pen above the page. “I’d like to see it.”

“You can. It won’t tell you where Vantage got one hundred and ten.”

“I know.”

Dov tore his flatbread in half. He had heard that answer from engineers before: I know, meaning they wanted to get past the objection. Noor was still looking at the dates.

“Could I photograph this?” she asked.

“Not yet. There are notes on the back about people who brought me notices.”

She turned the sheet over. Along the bottom edge were three initials and a telephone number. “I didn’t see those.”

“I nearly didn’t either.” He covered the writing with a scrap of card. “There.”

Noor took the photograph, checked it, then showed him the screen. The card concealed the notes. Dov nodded, and she put the phone away.

“Where did the plan come from?” she asked.

“Wick has it.”

Noor looked up from her notebook.

“Old municipal scheduler. Substation Nine. It kept local records when the link went down during the Sever.” Dov folded the laminate around the pencil again. “I’ve used it to check dates on some of the older papers.”

“Does it have later plans?”

“Not from Vantage. It hasn’t been connected to their systems.”

Noor closed her notebook. “I’d still like to see the plan.”

“I’ll take you when the lower gallery’s dry. There’s no point going down there to stand on the wrong side of the water.”

The door opened again. Yaz came in backward, dragging a printer by its cable.

“Someone left this outside,” they said. “If it gets any wetter, I’m charging it rent.”

“You could have carried it.”

“I could have. Then I’d have two wet hands.”

Dov took the cable before the plug caught on the threshold. Yaz spotted the flatbread bag, reached inside and found only a folded napkin.

“You brought breakfast,” they said to Noor.

“I brought two.”

“There are three of us.”

“You weren’t here.”

“That’s what Dov says about payment.”

Dov set the printer on the bench. “I pay you.”

“When you remember.”

Yaz pressed the power switch. Nothing happened. They sniffed the side vent, made a face and went to fetch tools.

Noor watched them open the casing. “Could the shop printer have made Delia’s receipt?”

“Not that original,” Dov said. “We copied it here. Cass took both notices away yesterday.”

“I remember. I was thinking about the print.”

Yaz lifted a warped roller between two fingers. “If you’re asking whether the machine invents the words, it doesn’t. Usually people blame the paper first.”

“Usually it is the paper,” Dov said.

“Usually you bought the paper.”

Noor smiled, then looked back at the schedule. “The same classification tells us where to look. It doesn’t tell us whether the funding rule survived.”

Dov put the sheet in its drawer. “That’s the part I wanted you to say.”


By evening the rain had stopped. Light from the walkway signs came through the shop window in broken red bars.

Noor had six copies arranged across the bench. Dov had selected them because their owners had already agreed that he could show the papers to people helping investigate their complaints. He had folded the names and identifying numbers underneath.

She moved one strip beside another.

“This one says a missed appointment. This says household composition. This one says district availability.”

“And that one says the applicant didn’t complete an identity check,” Dov said.

“Did they?”

“She says she did. I haven’t seen her confirmation.”

Noor marked a question in her notebook. On the next receipt, the stated reason was an address interruption. She hesitated over it.

“Do we have tenancy records?”

“Not here. The man who brought it said he’d moved twice.”

“So the interruption may be real.”

“It may.” Dov pulled up a stool. “He wanted to know why it mattered.”

Noor wrote that down too. A true address interruption could be an input without explaining how much it had affected the decision. She had no way to tell from the strip.

Yaz came through from the back, wiping black dust from their hands. “What are the numbers?”

“Positions on two of the notices,” Noor said. “The other four don’t show one.”

“Can the people tell what they mean?”

“Not from these.”

Yaz picked up the strip nearest them. Dov held out his hand.

“Fold the bottom first.”

Yaz did, then read it. “This says there was an appointment at a different clinic.”

“Availability in the district,” Noor said.

“That isn’t what it says. It says an alternative was available. Maybe it was across the water.”

Noor took the strip back and read the sentence again. “You’re right. I added the district.”

“Is that bad?”

“It could be, if I tell somebody that’s what the notice says.”

Yaz reached for a pencil. “Then write down what it says.”

Noor drew a line through her note and copied the wording. Yaz went back to the printer.

Dov laid another strip on the bench. “I can find you twenty that mention addresses.”

“Let’s check them one at a time,” Noor said.

Dov pushed the strip toward her.

Noor crossed out the heading Frequency above her columns.

“What are you putting instead?” he asked.

“The claim on each notice, and what its owner wants checked.”

Dov drew a clean sheet of till roll across the bench.

Noor took the pencil.

She hesitated over the first heading.

The six copies could suggest where to look; they could not tell her how often an error occurred across the city.

“Start with the notice,” Dov said.

“And the record behind the claim.”

Noor drew four columns: Notice; claim; record; owner’s permission.

Yaz returned with the dead roller. “That last one needs to come first.”

Noor looked at the headings. “It does.”

She tore the sheet off and started again. For the missed appointment, they could ask the owner whether she would show the cancellation message and appointment card. For the identity check, they could ask whether the applicant had a confirmation. Neither document would by itself explain the allocation decision.

“And the man who moved?” Dov asked.

“Ask what he wants checked. We shouldn’t assume his address history proves the reason false.”

Dov found a pencil stub and wrote two names on a separate scrap, shielding it with his hand. “I’ll contact them. They know me.”

“Would they be willing to talk to me?”

“They might. I’ll ask before giving you a name.”

Noor nodded. She added another column: What remains unknown.

The printer on the bench gave a dry click. Yaz had fitted a replacement roller and was feeding through a test strip. This time the black bars came out whole.

Dov held the strip up to the light. “You can have the last flatbread tomorrow.”

“There wasn’t a last one.”

“I’ll owe you.”

Yaz took the strip from him. “You already do.”

Noor gathered her notebook but left the copies where they were. At the top of the new sheet, the first column waited for an answer from someone outside the shop.