Chapter 22 of 35

AI-generated book by Adrian KnoxBook rights and permissions

Chapter 19: Schedule Four

The Board archive kept its paper in a room warmer than Noor expected. A vent hummed above the shelves, shifting the corner of a sign that asked visitors not to lean on the finding aids.

She gave the attendant her name and the number of the notice manual. He brought her a box with a fraying cloth handle and set it on the desk between them.

“Pencils only,” he said. “You can photograph anything without a red tab.”

The box contained three editions of Schedule Four, each amended with slips pasted over older text. Noor opened the newest. Its cover carried the Board seal and a date from 2041. A later note on the inside directed readers to an online register for current technical specifications.

She wrote down the address. Then she began with the paper.

Article Nine required a reason to be issued on paper. Schedule Four described what happened when that reason needed correction: an authorized body could submit a corrective notice independently of the service operator. The route had survived a challenge from two operators who argued that separate signing authority created an unacceptable security risk. The Board had rejected the challenge and required a narrow gateway instead.

Noor read the decision twice. It did not say which credentials the gateway would recognize now. It did not say whether Wick’s could sign the kind of work order Dov had found.

She turned to the technical appendix. Most of it had been superseded. A page describing notice fields remained in force, according to the register on her terminal, but its examples were generic: service identifier, decision date, contact route. Nothing established that the fields in Delia’s envelope would be available to a corrective template.

At the next table, a man in a maintenance jacket was copying figures from a bound volume. His pencil stopped whenever the ventilation fan changed pitch. Noor knew the feeling. She had come hoping that somewhere in the box there would be a sentence with a clear subject and verb: Wick may do this.

Instead she found another reference.

Schedule Four, subsection 8: preservation of notice state.

She requested the relevant file. The attendant returned with a thin folder and a warning that the last page was loose. Inside were forms for public requests to preserve the text of an active notice template. The Board auditor could take a time-stamped snapshot from the operator’s registered template service and keep a certified record.

The form allowed a requester to specify a time.

Noor put her pencil down.

A snapshot would show what the service presented as active. It would not tell her how Antecedent had ranked a household, or whether a paper kiosk had printed the template faithfully. But a record made outside Dov’s shop could show that a change had existed, even if Vantage restored the previous wording.

She photographed the form, then checked the scope notes. A request had to identify the service, template family and intended time. The auditor could reject one that was impossible to execute or sought protected personal data. There was no provision for the auditor to approve a template change.

“Can I ask who handles these?” she said when the attendant came to collect another box.

He glanced at the heading. “Auditor Nazari’s office, usually. The address is on the back.”

“Does he see the request before the specified time?”

“I should hope so.”

“I mean, does he contact the requester?”

“If he needs something clarified.”

Noor turned the form over. The office address was printed beneath a list of fees, most of them struck through by a later amendment. She copied the address into her notebook.

The attendant lifted the folder. “You’ll want the current form. That one’s an example.”

He pointed her to a terminal by the door. The current version asked for substantially the same information, with a small box requiring the requester to declare any known relationship to an anticipated change.

Noor left the box empty for the moment and saved nothing.

Outside, the afternoon had the flat brightness of rain held behind cloud. She stood under the archive awning and called Dov.

“I found a way to preserve the template state,” she said. “Through the Board.”

“Can they tell us whether the gateway accepts Wick?”

“This is separate. They can take a snapshot at a requested time, but it won’t test the gateway.”

A scrape came over the line. He was moving something heavy.

“Before and after?”

“Before and during, if we know when during is. We’d still need something later to show what happened after it stopped.”

“You’re certain the record is independent?”

“The auditor takes it from the registered service and keeps it. I haven’t spoken to him yet.”

Dov was quiet.

“He’ll see the times,” he said.

“Yes.”

“And ask why.”

“I think so.”

A bus passed, spraying the curb. Noor stepped farther beneath the awning.

“We don’t have a date,” she said. “I’m going to ask what he needs before we choose one.”


Nazari’s office smelled of coffee that had been ground recently and paper that had not. A worn filing cabinet stood against the wall behind his desk. Its top drawer was labelled LEGACY AUTHORITY, the card beneath the plastic cover yellowed at the edges.

He caught Noor looking at it.

“I’ve written about those credentials for eleven years,” he said. “The drawer was newer when I started.”

He offered her a cup. She accepted, though she had not expected one. The coffee was strong and hot enough to make her wait before drinking.

“You’re an engineer with Vantage,” he said, reading the appointment note.

“Reconciliation. My access is restricted at the moment.”

“That wasn’t on the form.”

“It seemed relevant.”

“Probably.” He placed the note beside a blank request. “You asked about two snapshots. Which template?”

Noor named the refusal-notice family they had identified in the public register. Nazari entered it, then asked for the service scope. She gave him the covered cardiac assessment notices, adding that she did not yet know which catchments or envelope variants would be eligible. She would update the requests when those were settled.

His fingers stopped on the keyboard.

“A proposed correction by whom?”

“I can’t give you a submitting authority.”

“Can’t or won’t?”

“I don’t have one confirmed.”

He studied her over the rim of his cup. “Are you asking me to approve a notice?”

“No.”

“Are you asking me to approve a deployment?”

“No.”

“Good. I can’t do either.”

Noor took the draft from her bag. It was a copy on ordinary paper, without Delia’s details or anyone else’s. Nazari read it silently, his thumb resting beside the line about modeled factors.

“This is not the current text,” he said.

“No.”

“Where did the ceiling and position come from?”

“They exist in at least one decision envelope I was authorized to examine. The draft would only be usable where the required fields are available.”

“An envelope isn’t the ranking model.”

“It only gives us the resulting fields.”

He read the paragraph again. “And this says a personal factor is not established as the sole cause. Established by whom?”

“That’s one of the things we’re still working on.”

“Then don’t tell me it’s finished.”

“It still needs work.”

He set the page down. “You understand why I’m asking.”

“Yes.”

Nazari leaned back. The chair gave a short mechanical complaint.

“A snapshot is a record of what the registered template service returns at a particular time. It will include the template identifier and the fields the service exposes to us. It will not show me who is entitled to print a notice, and it will not certify a paper copy somebody brings in later.”

“Can you preserve the wording and identifier independently of the operator?”

“Yes. The capture comes from the operator’s registered service. The resulting record is held by my office, with its own time stamp and custody entry.”

“Could the operator refuse the request?”

“They could fail to provide a response. That failure would be recorded too.”

Noor looked at the blank form. “If I request one shortly before a specified time and another shortly after, would that be enough?”

“Enough for what?”

“To establish a change.”

“If the captures show different states, they establish that the service returned different states at those times. There may be questions about when the change began, how widely it propagated and what was actually printed. You would need other evidence.”

He turned the form toward her. “You also need a time.”

“We’re considering the sixth of November.”

“We?”

Noor held his gaze. “Other people concerned about the notices.”

“Are you planning to make this change yourselves?”

She could hear the vent through the wall, a low vibration beneath the office’s silence.

“I’m asking you to preserve what the service returns,” she said.

“You haven’t answered me.”

“No.”

He tapped the declaration box. “The form asks about a known relationship to an anticipated change. If you submit it, answer that honestly.”

Noor looked at the draft between them. She could leave with the form and use another name. She could also give him a request that told him enough to act before anything happened.

“What happens if I say I expect a change?” she asked.

“I assess whether the request is within my authority. If I receive information about a specific threat to the service, I may have obligations beyond taking a snapshot. I won’t promise to ignore it.”

He let her consider that.

“I won’t use the snapshot procedure to authorize anything,” he added. “Nor will I promise that a record will make an unauthorized change lawful.”

“The request won’t make it lawful.”

Nazari regarded her over his cup.

She looked up. “I work with forms. I know a box doesn’t protect me because I’ve filled it in carefully.”

Something eased in his face, though he did not smile.

They settled on two requests for Saturday 6 November: one at 23:30 and one at 23:50, both for the registered cardiac-assessment refusal template, limited to its text, identifier and exposed field definitions. Leung and Patel could witness preservation on the sixth, but had not promised a later date. Waiting might give the group time to find more advisers; it would also leave misleading notices in use. Noor wrote that she was involved in discussions concerning a possible corrective notice. She did not identify the others or claim that a submission had been authorized.

Nazari read both forms and entered them into his register.

“These times are close together,” he said.

“They need to be.”

“If there’s no change, you’ll have two records of the same state.”

“That may be useful too.”

He printed acknowledgments, signed them and gave Noor a copy of each. His own copies went into a numbered folder. On the cover he wrote the dates and times, then carried it to the filing cabinet.

“Can you schedule a third?” Noor asked. “Later, if the template changes back?”

“I can accept another request for a later capture. I can’t tell you now what time would establish a rollback, and a snapshot alone might not establish who performed it.”

“I’ll ask if we need one.”

“Ask as early as you can.”

He closed the drawer. Noor folded the acknowledgments and put them beside the draft in her bag.

At the door, Nazari said, “Ms Abadi.”

She turned.

“If you obtain an actual notice, keep it. The template tells us what the service offered. Paper may tell us something else.”

Noor thought of Cass’s receipt, worn soft along its folds.

“I will,” she said.

He returned to his desk without asking for the draft. Noor left it there. On the way down the stairs she checked the acknowledgments once, making sure both times were legible. The second capture was scheduled for eleven minutes after the time Dov had tentatively suggested for a submission.

Eleven minutes in which the gateway might accept nothing at all.