Chapter 2: Appetite in the Round
The following week, Sil stood behind Malcolm in the planning office while he clicked through six screens and found three different names for the same number.
On the first it was a forecast. On the second it was a requirement. On the third it had become an approved quantity.
“Who approved it?” she asked.
“That’s what I’m trying to show you.”
Malcolm enlarged a box until the letters blurred. It contained a date, an authorisation code and the initials of someone who had left the company in December.
“Did she approve four thousand chairs?”
“She approved the plan. That doesn’t mean she looked at every line.”
Sil moved closer. The screen reflected the strip lights behind her. “Can we ask her?”
“I did. She remembers approving the plan.”
“Does she remember the Kestrels?”
“She asked whether we’d found a buyer.”
The door opened and Deepa came in with a notebook and a mug. She was a site administrator, and Malcolm had asked her to extract the older planning records because she knew how to get the system to produce them without printing the entire year.
“I’ve got the October model,” she said. “I haven’t got a sensible way to carry it.”
She put a sheaf of paper on the desk. Malcolm looked at its thickness.
“You could have sent it.”
“You said you wanted to see where the line came from. On the screen it keeps disappearing when I move across.”
She laid out four pages, overlapping them along the window ledge. A column headed Test contained a quantity entered against the Kestrel Pro.
Deepa tapped it. “This was a scenario. Someone wanted to see what would happen to the material forecast if demand rose.”
“For a discontinued chair?” Sil said.
“The scenario was made before it was discontinued. The model was copied forward afterwards.”
Malcolm put on his glasses. “That column should have been cleared.”
“It usually is. The new file was made from a copy before the old one was cleaned up.”
Sil looked at the figure. “Who entered it?”
“The planning analyst. I spoke to him. He knew it was a test.”
“And the person who copied it?”
“Knew she was copying the model. She didn’t know that line was still there.”
Malcolm pulled a chair up beside her. “Show me how it got into the plan.”
Deepa turned a page over and drew four boxes.
“Forecast. Plan. Schedule. Works order.”
“That’s a very short version,” Malcolm said.
“It’s a very small page.”
She drew an arrow from the first box to the second. The test quantity had appeared in the monthly forecast. A planner, working through exceptions, had queried the Kestrel line; the product code was still active because existing service orders needed it. She had been told the figure came from the demand model. She left it in.
The plan went for approval with other lines. The schedule divided the quantity across available production time. Works orders followed. Malcolm’s team bought components against them.
“Who told her it came from the model?” Sil asked.
Deepa checked her notebook. “The analyst.”
“The one who entered the test?”
“Yes. He checked where the figure came from. He didn’t realise it was his test.”
Malcolm sat back. “That’s unfortunate.”
Deepa looked at the papers. “It is now.”
He picked up the phone and called the analyst. Sil listened to his side of the conversation: a greeting, a request to check the model, a longer silence.
“No,” Malcolm said at last. “I’m not saying you ordered them. I’m asking whether there was anything on the screen that marked the number as a test.”
Another silence.
“Right. Thank you.”
He replaced the receiver. “There was. In the original file. The label didn’t come across in the forecast extract.”
Sil ran her finger along Deepa’s row of boxes. Each person had something to point to: a model, a forecast, an approved plan. By the time the chairs came off the line, the first entry had acquired enough paperwork to travel on its own.
“Can you pull the works orders?” she asked.
Malcolm gave her a look. “I can, but I know what they say.”
“I want to see them with Marlon.”
The Harrier cell was changing over when Sil reached the Long Shed. The conveyor slowed, then stopped in stages, its motor dropping through a series of descending notes. Two operators lifted an armrest jig from its mount and carried it to the rack.
The remaining twenty-four frames had come off the lorry on the day of Neville’s meeting. They were now being brought over from dispatch as needed. The driver had left with a signed delivery note and the last of the canteen’s ginger biscuits.
Marlon took the works orders from Sil and read the first page.
“We made eight hundred in that run,” he said.
“Was that unusual?”
“We make batches. The orders were there and the parts were there.” He turned the page. “This one was slotted in when the Harrier fabric was late. Kept people working.”
A woman at the jig rack called across to ask where he wanted a damaged clamp. He went to look at it, tested the spring and told her to put it in the maintenance tray. When he came back, Sil was still holding the second sheet.
“Did anyone ask about the Kestrels?” she said.
“I did. We’d stopped taking orders, so I asked planning why we were still making them. They said there was a requirement.”
“And you accepted that.”
Marlon folded his arms. “I asked the people who make the plan.”
“I’m not having a go.”
“You’ve brought the orders down to the floor.”
“Because I want to understand what happened on it.”
He studied her for a moment, then took her to the board beside the cell. Coloured cards marked the week’s work. One had been moved to make room for a maintenance job; another carried a handwritten note about a missing component.
“If an order looks wrong, we ask,” he said. “Sometimes it is wrong. Sometimes sales has a customer we haven’t heard about. Sometimes we’re building stock ahead of a promotion. Planning tells us which.”
“Did you get the answer in writing?”
“I probably got it in an email. Do you want me to find it?”
“Yes.”
“Will it help?”
“It might.”
He nodded once. “That makes two of us.”
At the far end of the shed, the Kestrels remained under their plastic. Sil could see the gap where the six pallets had been moved into the inspection area. It had been useful for less than a day; a delivery of packaging now occupied most of it.
Marlon followed her gaze. “Ophelia’s asking sales what they can do.”
“She’s not offering them as new stock without checking them.”
“That’s a relief.”
“You were hoping she would?”
“I was hoping for an answer by Friday.”
Sil handed him the other works orders. “Deepa’s found the start of it. A test quantity was copied into a forecast. It went through planning, scheduling and purchasing.”
“So who decided to make them?”
“That’s the question Neville will ask.”
“And what will you tell him?”
Sil listened to the cell start again. One section of conveyor moved, then the next, until the frames were travelling past the operators at their usual pace.
“I’ll tell him what we found.”
Rufus Deane had planned to take the 16:12 train. He had the timetable open on his phone when Neville called back.
He answered and pushed his chair away from the meeting-room wall. It was cold enough through his jacket to make him shift forward again.
“Have you got a name?” Rufus asked.
“There are several names.”
“That’s not quite what I meant.”
Neville explained the test line and the copied model. Rufus made notes on the back of a financing-review agenda: forecast, plan, schedule, works order. Neville’s account was careful. At each stage someone had checked that an earlier stage existed.
“Who had authority to remove the quantity?” Rufus asked.
“Planning could have queried it.”
“Could they remove it?”
“I’d need to establish that.”
“And who could stop the run once it started?”
“Production could raise a concern.”
“I’m sure they could. Who could stop it?”
There was a pause. Rufus could hear paper moving at Neville’s end.
“Potentially several people.”
“Which one should I speak to before the financing review?”
“I can bring the relevant people together.”
“I don’t need a meeting with everyone involved. I need someone who can tell me whether the same thing is happening with another product.”
Neville said, “We’re checking the current plan.”
“Who is?”
“Malcolm is looking at purchasing, and the planning team—”
“Neville,” Rufus interrupted.
“Yes. I’ve asked the planning manager to check it. She’ll report to me tomorrow.”
“Good. Send me her findings.”
Rufus glanced at the agenda. The lenders would receive the ordinary stock figures before the review, and four thousand discontinued chairs would be conspicuous in any explanation of working capital. The company had bought Brackwell & Vane in 2019 because it made a reliable product and had a customer base worth keeping. He did not want to spend the review explaining that nobody could say how its factory had come to make seven weeks’ worth of unwanted chairs.
“Can you sell them?” he asked.
“Ophelia is assessing that.”
“At what price?”
“She hasn’t finished the assessment.”
“Then I’ll wait for it.”
He ended the call and looked again at his notes. There was no shortage of activity in Neville’s account. His difficulty was finding the person who could give him an answer that bound the others.
Rufus searched his contacts and rang Priti Shah at Kessel Bright. They had spoken at a Corbelay event about operational controls. She answered on the second attempt.
“I have a company with four thousand chairs it didn’t mean to make,” he said.
“Are they good chairs?”
“I’m told they are.”
“Then you’re ahead of some of our clients.”
He gave her the brief version. She asked what had happened when someone queried the forecast, who signed the production plan and whether the approval meant checking its contents. Rufus answered what he could.
“We can send someone to look at how decisions move through the business,” she said.
“How quickly?”
“I’ll have to check who’s free.”
“I need an assessment before our financing review. I don’t want a hunt for someone to dismiss.”
“Good. That would be a different fee.”
He smiled despite himself. “Send me a proposal today.”
“And access to the people doing the work?”
“You’ll have it.”
After the call he emailed Neville: Kessel Bright will contact you about a review. Please make the site available.
He checked the train timetable again. The 16:12 had gone. There was another at 16:48, which left him time to call the planning manager himself.