Chapter 19 of 35

AI-generated book by Nora WestleyBook rights and permissions

Chapter 16: The Case in the Jacket

Marjorie’s telephone rang six times on Wednesday morning before I put the receiver down. I tried again after opening the shop and heard the same patient ringing.

“She may be in the garden,” Ivy said.

“She may. Or she may have gone out.”

Ivy glanced at the receiver. “Would you like me to keep answering until she gets back?”

“I don’t think telephones work like that.”

“It would save you dialling.”

She was arranging the local books, with a strip of card propped against the shelf to keep them upright. I had promised to collect the new honey labels from Ferring that afternoon, and she was working out how many jars we could put beside the books without making it impossible to reach them.

The bell rang. Dawn came in carrying an empty honey jar and a folded shopping bag.

“I thought I’d bring this back,” she said. “Though I expect you’ve got more than enough.”

“We always need jars.” I took it from her. “Would you like another?”

“Not today, thank you. I’ve still got half the last one.”

She looked tired, but her hair was neatly pinned, and she had put on a green jacket I had not seen before. Ivy asked if she liked the display.

“I do,” Dawn said. “Can you fit another book at that end?”

“Only if Cora agrees to move the till.”

“The till stays,” I said.

“That’s what she said last time.”

Dawn smiled, then turned to me. “Are you busy this morning?”

“Ivy’s here until lunch. Why?”

“There’s something I remembered about Marjorie’s visit. The day before the fair.” She rubbed a thumb along the handle of her bag. “I wondered whether I should have mentioned it when the police came. I’d rather talk without an audience.”

Ivy picked up her strip of card. “I can be a very quiet audience.”

“I know,” Dawn said. “But I’d still rather.”

“Right.” Ivy carried the books towards the window. “I’ll be over here, loudly not listening.”

Dawn’s house was ten minutes away on foot. I fetched my coat and told Ivy where the spare roll of price stickers was, though she had been the one to put it there.


Dawn made tea and set two cups on the kitchen table. The honey jar I had brought her stood by the breadboard, its lid screwed on at an angle.

“I’ve been trying to remember that Friday properly,” she said. “Not just the bit I’ve gone over since the fair.”

“You told me the case had been found.”

“Yes. Gil had put it in the pocket of another jacket. He was cross with me for not knowing where it was.”

“Had he asked you to keep track of it?”

“He expected me to keep track of most things.” She straightened the lid. “He knew perfectly well he’d moved it himself.”

I waited while she poured the tea.

“Marjorie came in the afternoon,” Dawn said. “Gil had asked her to look at the case. He said the fastening was awkward, and he wanted to be sure he could get at it quickly.”

“Was he having trouble with it?”

“He said he was. I don’t know whether he wanted help or an opportunity to complain.”

I remembered Marjorie telling me that Gil had sought her practical help. At the time I had been more interested in what she might say about Nell.

“Did you see them together?” I asked.

“I let Marjorie in. Gil brought the jacket down and took the case out to show her. They were in the sitting room.”

“Were you there?”

“For a little while. Then Gil asked for tea. He followed me into the kitchen because he wanted to know whether I’d found the fair schedules. He’d left the jacket and the case in the sitting room with Marjorie.”

“How long were you gone?”

Dawn considered. “A few minutes, perhaps. I filled the kettle, and he looked through the papers on the dresser. Then I went back in with the tray. He came after me.”

“And the jacket?”

“On the chair where he’d put it. Marjorie was standing by the window.” Dawn held her cup in both hands. “I didn’t see what she did while we were out. She might have looked at the fastening, as he’d asked. She might have done nothing.”

“Did anyone else come in?”

“Not while I was there. The front door was shut.” She looked at me. “I can’t tell you what happened every moment of that afternoon, Cora.”

“I’m sorry. I’m asking as though you can.”

“I’ve been doing the same to myself.”

A clock ticked above the dresser. I could hear a tap dripping in the scullery, each drop landing a little ahead of the next tick.

“Did Gil say anything afterwards?” I asked.

“He put the case back in his pocket. They talked about the fair, and Marjorie had half a cup of tea before she left. You arrived to collect the schedule just as she was going.”

I had seen Marjorie on the doorstep, her cardigan over her arm. I had been thinking about how strained Dawn looked and had scarcely noticed what Gil was carrying.

“Did you know about his allergy before then?” I asked.

“Yes. He’d had a bad reaction some years ago. He saw his doctor and was given the device to carry.” Dawn traced the rim of her saucer. “He was particular about it when he remembered. I used to check he had the case if we were going somewhere with the bees.”

“At the fair, you knew where to find it.”

“In his jacket pocket. He’d told me that morning.” She paused. “I keep thinking I ought to have checked it before we left.”

“You had no reason to think—”

“I don’t know what I had reason to think.” Her voice sharpened, then softened. “Sorry. Everyone has been very ready to tell me what I ought or ought not to have done.”

I set down my cup. “Then I’ll stop.”

She gave a small nod. Outside, a delivery van turned in the lane and reversed with several indignant beeps.

“Would you tell Detective Sergeant Okonkwo what you’ve told me?” I asked.

“Yes. I’ll ring her after lunch.” Dawn reached for the shopping bag. “I wrote down a few things this morning, so I wouldn’t lose my place.”

A folded sheet lay inside. She did not take it out, and I did not ask to see it.

“I nearly went straight to Marjorie,” I said. “I’ve been trying to arrange a visit.”

“About Nell?”

“Among other things.”

Dawn looked towards the garden. “If you do see her, please don’t repeat my account as if I’d watched the whole visit. I was in and out.”

“I won’t.”

“And I’d rather tell the detective myself.”

“Of course.”

She walked me to the door. On the step she said, “Marjorie brought me soup after my mother died. She came every Tuesday for a month, even when I told her I had plenty in the freezer.”

“That sounds like her.”

“She brought too much pepper.” Dawn managed a smile. “I thought you ought to have the complete account.”


At half past two I was in Ferring with a box of labels under one arm when my telephone rang. Okonkwo asked whether I could come to the station that afternoon.

“I’m only two streets away,” I said. “Has something happened?”

“I’d like to clarify a few points from your earlier account. Can you manage three o’clock?”

The labels fitted under the chair in the interview room, though the box stuck out far enough for me to catch my ankle on it. Okonkwo waited while I pushed it back.

“Business going well?” she asked.

“We’re about to label a great many jars. Beyond that, I’m keeping an open mind.”

She sat opposite me with a notebook. “You saw Marjorie Plum leaving the Prendergast house on the Friday before the fair.”

“Yes. Dawn had invited me to collect a schedule. Marjorie was coming out as I arrived.”

“Did you see what she was carrying?”

“She had a cardigan over her arm. I remember her putting it on before she left. I can’t be certain what else she had.”

“Did she have a coat over her arm?”

“The cardigan, rather than a coat. Gil had his jacket when he came to the door afterwards.”

Okonkwo wrote that down. She asked what I had seen when Dawn retrieved the case at the fair. I described Dawn reaching into Gil’s jacket and bringing it over. Beyond that, the sequence became crowded: people calling out, Marjorie kneeling, someone asking us to move back.

“Did you handle the case?” Okonkwo asked.

“No.”

“Or see it again after the responders took over?”

“No.”

She closed her notebook but kept her hand on it. “The case and its contents have been examined. There’s an inconsistency we need to follow up.”

I felt my fingers tighten around the strap of my handbag. “What sort of inconsistency?”

“I can’t give you the details at this stage. We’re checking the records of what was collected and who handled it, and the relevant supply information.”

“Does it mean someone interfered with it?”

“It means we have a question. We’re trying to establish the answer.”

I thought of Dawn leaving the sitting room, Marjorie by the window, the jacket on the chair. I also thought of the busy marquee and the case in Gil’s pocket throughout the fair.

“Dawn remembered something about the visit,” I said. “She’s going to contact you herself.”

“Thank you. I’ll speak to her.”

I hesitated. “Was the medication the reason he died?”

Okonkwo’s expression remained composed. “I’m not going to draw that conclusion from what I’ve told you. The medical evidence is being considered by the appropriate people.”

The room was warm. I unbuttoned my coat, then realised I had never taken it off.

“I wanted there to be an answer,” I said.

“I’ll let you know if we need anything more from you.”

She stood, and I retrieved my box from under the chair. On my way out I caught it against the doorframe. Okonkwo held the door while I turned the box sideways.

I tried to manoeuvre the box through.

“The other way,” she suggested.

It went through easily once I did as I was told.

On the bus home I took out my telephone to call Marjorie. I had her number open before I remembered Dawn’s request. I put the telephone away again and held the box of labels steady on my knees, listening to the jars inside my shopping bag knock gently together at each turn.