Chapter 21 of 35

AI-generated book by Nora WestleyBook rights and permissions

Chapter 18: Dawn’s Story

Rain had found the loose corner of Dawn’s kitchen gutter. It struck the paving stone outside at regular intervals, each splash spreading over the one before.

“I’ve put a bowl there twice,” Dawn said, following my gaze. “Gil moved it because he said it looked untidy.”

“Did he mend the gutter?”

“He said the bowl looked untidy.”

She set a plate of toast between us and sat down. I had called to ask whether she needed anything from the square, and she had invited me round. At the door she took my wet coat, then asked if I had time for tea. She had written a telephone number on a pad beside her cup.

“Detective Sergeant Okonkwo is expecting me to ring,” she said. “About what I remembered of Marjorie’s visit. There’s something else I think I should tell her.”

I waited.

“Do you remember Nell Plum’s funeral?”

“Yes. I was fourteen.”

“You were standing with Peg. You had a blue coat with a missing button.”

“I thought no one noticed.”

“I noticed because you kept trying to hold it closed.” Dawn touched the edge of the pad. “I was thirty-one. Gil and I had been married for years by then.”

She pushed the toast towards me. I took a piece, although the butter had already soaked through it.

“Nell died at the orchard cottage,” Dawn said. “I wasn’t there. I was here, in the house. It was late when Marjorie came to the door.”

“Did you let her in?”

“Gil did. I was upstairs. I heard them in the hall and came down as far as the turn in the stairs.” She glanced towards the doorway, as though measuring the distance. “Marjorie said Nell needed help urgently. She wanted him to call a doctor.”

“What did he do?”

“He asked her what had happened. She kept saying there wasn’t time to explain. He asked again.”

The rain rattled harder against the window. Dawn picked up her cup and found it empty. I reached for the teapot, but she shook her head.

“I couldn’t see them from where I stood,” she said. “I heard Marjorie say, ‘Please, Gil.’ More than once. Then he said she should go back to Nell and he would deal with it.”

“Did he make the call?”

“Eventually. I heard him on the telephone after Marjorie had gone.” Dawn pressed her thumb against the cup handle. “I can’t tell you how many minutes passed. I was frightened, and I wasn’t watching a clock.”

“Did you ask him what was wrong?”

“He told me to go back to bed. I didn’t. I went into the kitchen, and when he came in I asked again.” She gave a short, breathless laugh. “I can still see the dishcloth in his hand. He’d picked it up from the sink and was folding it into a little square.”

“What did he say?”

“That there had been trouble at the cottage, and I was to leave him to manage it.”

Dawn pulled the plate closer and tore a strip from her toast without eating it.

“Later, after Nell died, he told me the account we were to give. Nell had become ill suddenly. A doctor had been called. He said there was no need to add anything else.”

“That was what people were told.”

“Yes. I told it too.” She looked at me. “It wasn’t a complete account. I knew Marjorie had come here asking for help, and I knew he hadn’t called at once.”

I thought of Bram at the post office, handed a folded note the following morning. He had never claimed to know who had made the call. I had wanted the pieces of his memory to cover more ground than they did.

“Did Gil tell you why he waited?” I asked.

“He gave me different answers over the years. Once he said he’d been trying to understand what Marjorie wanted. Another time he said she’d come to him because she trusted him to be discreet.” Dawn rubbed the toast crumbs from her fingers. “He could make an answer sound very reasonable if he had long enough to work on it.”

“Did Marjorie ever speak to you about that night?”

“Some years later. Not all of it.” Dawn paused. “I knew there was more to the emergency than I’d heard on the stairs. Gil let things slip, and Marjorie told me a little. They didn’t tell me the same things, and I can’t always remember which of them said what.”

I wanted to ask about the child Bram had mentioned, about Edmund in the photograph. Dawn had already set down one boundary, and I could see her deciding whether she had the strength to hold another.

“Do you think Nell would have lived if he’d called sooner?” I asked.

“I don’t know.” Her answer came quickly. “I’ve asked myself that for thirty years. I wasn’t at the cottage. I don’t know what the doctor found when he arrived, and I won’t pretend I do.”

“I’m sorry.”

“I know you are.” She gathered the crumbs into her palm. “I used to think if I could remember the exact words, or the exact time, I might be able to settle it. But I can tell the detective what I heard without settling it.”

She tipped the crumbs into the bin and returned to the table. The telephone number was written carefully, with a line beneath it.

“Would you like me to stay while you ring?” I asked.

“No. I’d like to make the call myself.” She looked at the toast. “You can take that last piece, though. It’s going cold while we’re both being brave.”

I took it. “I wasn’t aware I was being brave.”

“You came out in this rain without an umbrella.”

“I left it on the bus yesterday.”

“That sounds more like you.”

She smiled, and for a moment her face lost the strained, watchful look I had come to know. When I left, she was still at the table, turning the pad towards her.


By afternoon the rain had stopped, though the square remained shiny and the flower buckets outside Marnie’s shop stood in shallow puddles. I unlocked Peg’s notebook from the drawer behind the counter and opened it beside the till.

I found Peg’s note about Marjorie’s confidence and her wish to let Marjorie decide.

The sentence was dated years after Nell’s death. Dawn’s account did not tell me what Marjorie had confided to Peg, or when Peg had learned it. I put a finger on the date, then closed the notebook and locked it away again.

Bram’s photograph was back with him; Tom and I had returned it the previous evening. Nell’s raised hand stayed with me, the awkward pose of someone caught in bright sun. A photograph could preserve that much and still leave nearly everything outside its edges.

The connecting door opened, and Marnie came through carrying a bunch of stems.

“Do you have a jug I can borrow? Mine has developed a leak.”

I found one beneath the counter. She filled it from the little sink and put the flowers in, then studied me over their heads.

“You’ve got your thinking face on.”

“I have several.”

“This is the one that makes people check whether they’ve left the oven on.”

“I went to see Dawn.”

Marnie adjusted a drooping stem. “Is she all right?”

“She’s had a difficult morning. She’s going to speak to Okonkwo.” I hesitated. “The old story about Nell is more complicated than the gossip made it sound.”

Marnie’s hand stopped among the flowers. “Did Dawn tell you what happened?”

“She told me some of what she heard. It’s hers to give to the detective.”

Marnie looked as if she might argue. Instead she lifted the jug, considered its weight and set it down again.

“Fair enough,” she said. “I asked about Dawn. I should have left it there.”

“I know you care about her.”

“I can care and still be a nuisance.” She picked up the jug once more. “Will you tell her I’ve put those pink geraniums aside? She liked them last week. No charge for keeping them alive until she’s ready.”

“I will. Though she may have something to say about the no charge.”

“I haven’t said I’m giving them away. I’m charging her for the plants, not my excellent conversation.”

After she had gone, Ivy came down from the window with a sheet of paper held in front of her.

“I’ve made the heading smaller,” she said. “Now there’s room for something about the orchard.”

She laid the sheet on the counter. She had drawn a branch along the top, with apples hanging from it and a bee that looked considerably more businesslike than any bee I knew.

“What sort of something?” I asked.

“Dates, perhaps. Bram said there used to be a cottage there. And there’s Nell’s tree.”

I reached for the pencil beside the till, then put it down. “What would you want people to know?”

“That the orchard’s been used for things besides looking pretty.” Ivy pointed to the blank space. “We could ask Rufus about the trees. And Bram about the cottage, if he remembers it.”

“He does. We’d need to be clear about what he actually knows.”

Ivy raised an eyebrow. “I know how to ask a question.”

“You do. I’m reminding myself.”

She turned the paper towards her. “Should Nell go on it?”

The bell rang as a customer came in, shaking water from a folded newspaper. Ivy waited while I sold him a jar of honey and wrapped it against the damp. When he had gone, she was still holding the pencil.

“We can say there’s a tree in her memory,” I said. “If we check that with Marjorie first.”

“And nothing else?”

“Not until we know what belongs in a public display, and who can tell us.”

Ivy considered this. “If we leave too much out, people might think nothing happened there.”

“Yes. That would be a problem too.”

She wrote ask Marjorie in the margin, then added Rufus—trees beneath it.

“I’ll start with the apples,” she said. “They’re less likely to object.”

She carried the sheet back to the window. I watched her tape it up, stand back and move it an inch to the left. Across the square, Dawn came out of the lane with her coat buttoned and her hair uncovered. She paused outside Marnie’s shop, looking at the geraniums through the glass.

I could not tell whether she had made her call. Marnie opened the door, and Dawn went inside.