Chapter 15: Wine and the Argument
The cat opened the door.
It had one white paw and a bandage around the other, and it came through the gap before Cosima could stop it. I caught it against my shins. It bit my glove without conviction.
“An excellent judge of character,” Cosima said.
She bent to retrieve it, but the cat escaped under a chair on the landing. Cosima straightened with a small sigh.
“I’ll leave the door open. He’ll come back when he remembers dinner.”
“You’re feeding him too?”
“I was referring to the fish.”
The flat smelled of burnt butter. Below us, the bookshop was dark, though I could see a strip of light beneath the door to its back room. Cosima led me into a sitting room crowded with books and a drying rack hung with children’s socks.
“I thought you might bring Aurel.”
“You invited me to ask questions.”
“I did. May I take your coat?”
I kept my bag and handed it over. Petra’s mouthpiece was inside, wrapped in its handkerchief. The previous night I had stood on the road below Ashfield chapel with the bag against my hip, listening to two thin notes rise from somewhere beyond the locked gate. I had sung them back, badly. The second had come again.
I had told Aurel about the walk. I had not yet told him what I heard. I wanted to know first whether I could have mistaken an echo, or a bird in the trees.
Cosima carried in two plates. The fish had stuck to the pan and arrived in several pieces, with potatoes that offered more resistance than their colour suggested.
“I should warn you,” she said, “I’m better at breakfast.”
I tasted a potato. “How much better?”
“Considerably.”
She poured wine. I let her fill my glass but left it on the table.
For a while she asked about the workshop, and I answered because the questions were specific. She knew the organ at St Ivo’s had a troublesome reed and wanted to know whether the church could afford the repair.
“Father Benedek thinks prayer will improve the estimate,” I said.
“Has it?”
“He’s still praying.”
She smiled, then watched me put down my fork.
“You didn’t come to discuss the organ.”
“Petra borrowed a flute on the second. Petan returned it that night.”
The smile left her face. She set her own fork across her plate.
“Did Juno tell you that?”
“I’m asking you.”
“Yes. Petan returned it.”
“Why?”
“Petra had gone somewhere she shouldn’t have been. I sent him to bring her back.”
“To you?”
“To the Undercroft, initially.”
“What did you want from her?”
Cosima lifted her glass, then set it down untouched. “She had been making copies of restricted records. Petan told me she was carrying an account in a message note. I wanted to know what was in it and who else had seen the records.”
“She died.”
“I know.”
The cat emerged from beneath the chair and rubbed its unbandaged side against Cosima’s ankle. She reached down automatically, but it ducked away.
“Did Petan pull what she was carrying?” I asked.
Her fingers remained open beside the chair.
“I told him to stop her leaving with the note. I hoped he could recover the papers too.”
“That isn’t an answer.”
“He knew what I meant.”
My mouth had gone dry. “You told him to extract it.”
“I told him she must not take it out of the tower.” Cosima looked at me steadily. “I knew extraction was a possibility. I knew the risk.”
“And you sent him anyway.”
“Yes.”
I pushed my chair back. Its leg caught on a seam in the rug.
“She reached St Ivo’s,” I said. “She was bleeding. She asked me to tell Juno it wasn’t the count.”
Cosima closed her eyes briefly. “The count was the explanation Petan gave me.”
“Did you believe him?”
“At first.” She opened her eyes. “By the time I had reason to doubt him, Juno had already been told.”
“You could have corrected it.”
“I should have.”
I stood, gripping the back of the chair. “You can still tell her.”
“I will speak to Juno.”
“When?”
“When I have the records in front of me and can tell her precisely what happened.”
“You’ve had nearly two weeks.”
“And you have no reason to accept another delay.” Her voice sharpened. “I understand that. Sit down, Mara. If you walk out now, you’ll have one answer and none of the others.”
I wanted to leave her with the cold fish and the cat. Instead I pulled the chair free of the rug and sat.
“What records was Petra copying?”
“Ward measurements. Old reports from Ashfield. Anything she could find about the Close.” Cosima rose and crossed to a cabinet. “She was clever enough to see the figures were being kept apart. She wasn’t the only one.”
She brought back a folder and laid three sheets beside my plate. Columns of dates and measurements ran down each page. Several entries were circled in red.
“The east retaining wall,” she said, pointing to one. “Cracks measured each winter. We’ve repaired the stone twice. The rate is still increasing.”
“That could be the ground moving.”
“It could. This is the river level at the lower sluice, compared with the pressure recorded at the tower. And these are the ward readings from the infirmary.”
I followed her finger. The numbers fell unevenly over the years; one had risen before falling again.
“What do the units mean?”
“They’re a standard test carried by the same three people, for as long as we can manage it. Not perfect. That woman died in 2016, so the series changes there.” Cosima tapped the page. “The decline is real, even allowing for her replacement.”
“You’ve shown this to the Houses?”
“To their heads. Some think I’ve selected the worst readings. Some think the wards will settle if we leave them alone.”
“And what do you think?”
“I think we’ve spent years arguing while the margin gets smaller.”
The cat jumped onto the empty chair, favouring its bandaged paw. Cosima broke off a piece of fish and held it out. This time it accepted.
“My grandson fell down the stairs in October,” she said. “He broke his wrist. Children do. The ward didn’t prevent it, and I don’t pretend it should have. But if the river comes over the quay, or a fire takes hold in the old streets, I’d like the protection we have left to be working.”
“Tobias was hurt because someone deceived him. Petra was hurt because someone took from her. Does that enter your figures?”
Cosima’s hand stopped above the cat. “Yes. It enters mine.”
“Not enough to stop Petan.”
“No.”
The admission gave me nowhere comfortable to put my anger. I picked up my glass and took a mouthful of wine. It was sharp and cold.
Cosima sat again. “My grandchildren can’t hear the call. Neither has a compass. Their mother was told there was little point bringing them to lessons.”
“By whom?”
“By people whose names I can give you, if you’d like to quarrel with them. I have already done it.”
“And did you change the rule?”
“I got them into the room. That isn’t the same as changing the rule.” She glanced at the small socks on the rack. “They’re perfectly capable children. They should have a place in the Consort whether or not they can carry a note.”
“Then give them one.”
“I’m trying.”
“You’re First Chair.”
“And the Chair has a vote, not a crown.” She gathered the measurements into a stack. “I can press the Houses. I can’t make them agree that a child without compass belongs at the table. I can try to keep the table standing long enough for that child to have the argument.”
She took my plate away before I had finished. In the kitchen, a tap ran; a cupboard opened and shut. I heard her swear softly when something fell.
When she returned, she carried the wine bottle and no food.
“The sound at Ashfield is failing,” she said. “What was taken in 1811 has been used for two hundred and ten years. The binding needs renewing.”
“With what?”
“More of the spring’s sound.”
I looked at her. “You mean to take it again.”
“I mean to draw enough to strengthen the wards.”
“Does the spring get a vote?”
“It’s a spring, Mara.”
“Ilona thought it could be returned.”
“Ilona thought many things. She was often brilliant and occasionally impossible to feed.”
“She put the Close in me to keep it from you.”
Cosima’s grip tightened on the bottle. Wine trembled at its neck.
“Yes,” she said. “I suspected that after Monday.”
“You saw two notes. You don’t know what the rest will do.”
“No. But I know what happened when the four phrases met it.” She set the bottle down. “We can use that response.”
“We?”
“The players. With you there.”
“You haven’t asked what I want.”
“I’m asking you to listen.”
“I have been.”
The cat began washing its bandage. Cosima moved it gently from the paw, and it objected with a low growl.
“If the spring can answer,” I said, “we could ask it.”
“To do what?”
“To give back what’s needed. Or hear what it wants done.”
Cosima shook her head. “Water carries sound. Chalk carries it. A wall can send your voice back to you. None of those things is a person waiting for a question.”
Last night, on the Ashfield road, I had waited after the second note. The answer had come only once. I had tried again until my throat hurt and heard nothing but traffic below the hill.
Perhaps Cosima was right. I was not willing to hand her that possibility as proof.
“You don’t know there’s nobody listening,” I said.
“And you don’t know there is.” She leaned toward me. “If you’re wrong, how many years do we spend asking while the wards fail?”
“I don’t know. How much do you take before you decide you’ve taken enough?”
For the first time she had no answer ready. The cat jumped down and limped toward the kitchen.
“I loved your mother,” Cosima said.
I thought of Ilona’s copies, damp at the corners, and of Osip’s basket.
“That didn’t make you agree.”
“No.” Cosima’s gaze moved to the dark window. “It didn’t make either of us kinder, at the end.”
I stood and reached for my bag. She did not try to stop me this time. At the door she brought my coat and held it while I put my arms through.
“Tell Juno,” I said.
“I heard you.”
“That isn’t the same thing.”
Her hand remained on the door after she opened it. “Be careful on your way home.”
Downstairs, the bookshop’s back-room light had gone out. I stepped onto Weir Street alone, pulled my coat close and headed toward the corner. I wanted to get back to Ashfield with someone who could listen beside me.