Chapter 21 of 35

AI-generated book by Felix FinchBook rights and permissions

Chapter 18: Forty-One Promises

Wole came to my desk holding an invoice reminder and a sandwich in a paper bag.

“Have you seen Marty?” he asked.

“Not today.”

“He was meant to send these at eleven.”

Wole managed Accounts Receivable. He had a way of asking questions that left room for a reasonable explanation, though the sandwich suggested he had already looked in the places where reasonable explanations were usually found.

“Is he at lunch?” I asked.

“He bought it at twelve. I found it on his desk.”

We found Marty on the twelfth floor, in a meeting room with a woman from Marketing and a spreadsheet projected on the wall. He was entering campaign costs while she read figures from a stack of receipts.

“Marty,” Wole said.

Marty turned. “I’ll be down in ten.”

“You said that at twelve-thirty.”

The woman lowered her papers. “I asked him to help me finish this. We have a review tomorrow.”

“And I need him to send reminders before three,” Wole said.

Marty closed the spreadsheet. “I can do both.”

“You’ve been doing both since Monday.”

The woman gathered her receipts. “I can finish it.”

“I said I would,” Marty told her.

She looked from him to Wole. “You also said Finance would transfer us a slot.”

“I’m working on that.”

Wole held out the sandwich. Marty took it without looking at the bag.

Back downstairs, Wole asked him to send the reminders first. Marty sat at his desk, moved the sandwich clear of the keyboard and opened the invoice queue. Wole waited until the first messages were going out before following me into the aisle.

“He’s been covering tasks for people all week,” he said. “Yesterday it was a Sales report. Before that, somebody’s client list.”

“Have you asked why?”

“He says he’s helping.”

I looked towards Marty. He was reading an invoice, lips moving slightly as he checked the amount.

“Did you approve those arrangements?”

“I approved one transfer in December. Finance had a permission available, and he’d found a team that needed it. I didn’t approve him promising away our next three quarters.”

“Have you seen the promises?”

“Some.” Wole took a folded sheet from his pocket. “He gave me this when I asked why he needed Wednesday afternoon.”

The sheet listed teams, dates and numbers, with several names pencilled in the margin. At the bottom Marty had written 41, circled twice.

“Forty-one what?” I asked.

“He said promises to deliver. Not slots he has.”

I recognised several counterparties from the Ledger. Other entries referred to agreements made before it launched. The dates ran from January through March. Beside some entries Marty had written pending lead approval; beside others, replacement?

“How many are Finance commitments?” I asked.

“That’s what I want to know. He can post offers. He can’t bind Finance whenever somebody accepts one.”

We went back to Marty’s desk. He had sent eight reminders and opened the ninth.

“Can this wait ten minutes?” he asked.

“Yes,” Wole said. “Send that one, then come with us.”

In a small room off the AR row, Marty spread the sheet flat. He had used the reverse of an old meeting agenda, and the heading Q4 REVENUE showed faintly through his figures.

“Some of those are the same supply,” he said before either of us asked. “I thought I could get releases on the earlier ones if the later transfer went through.”

“You promised the same slots twice?” I said.

“I promised delivery. I hadn’t identified all the slots yet.”

Wole sat down. “What did you tell the people you promised?”

“That I was arranging them.”

“All of them?”

Marty picked at the edge of the paper. “Some of them thought I had approval.”

“Did you tell them you did?”

“I told them Wole had signed transfers before.”

Wole made a sound and stopped himself. “I signed particular transfers.”

“I know that now.”

Marty opened his laptop and showed us the Ledger alongside an older folder of emails. Some promises had been fulfilled. Others had missed their delivery dates. He had tried to obtain replacement permissions, then offered his time when he could not.

“The campaign work was for Leanne,” he said. “Her team moved a session because I said I’d get them a March slot. They had to do the review in pieces.”

“Did she ask you to enter receipts?” Wole said.

“I offered.”

“During your AR hours?”

“She needed them done.”

Wole looked at the sandwich, still in Marty’s hand. “So do we.”

Marty put it on the table. “I’m not asking AR to cover for me.”

“You’ve missed work, Marty. We’re already covering.”

I asked whether I could take a copy of the list. He hesitated, then turned the page towards me.

“Please don’t send it to everyone.”

“I won’t. Bettina needs to see the agreements, and we’ll need the records from Simon. I’ll tell you who else before I share it.”

Marty nodded. Wole asked him to finish the invoice run and leave the other teams’ work until they had spoken again. Marty opened his mouth, then shut it.

“What do I tell Leanne?” he asked.

“Tell her you have AR work to complete,” Wole said. “If she needs to speak to someone, she can call me.”

Marty picked up the sandwich and went back to his desk.

Wole stayed behind. “I should have asked sooner.”

“He was trying to handle it himself.”

“That’s what worries me. He’s very good at looking busy.”

I took a photograph of the list, with Marty’s permission, and sent it to Bettina. Her reply came back before I reached my desk.

Please bring the underlying agreements. The number alone cannot tell us what is owed.


Two days later, Bettina reserved a small meeting room and covered its table with printouts. Marty brought his laptop. Simon brought his own records and asked whether he should shut the door.

“Yes,” Bettina said. “And sit down.”

Four screens showed versions of the same history. Mine held the Ledger export; Marty’s had emails and his working sheet; Simon had the Book’s old listings and messages. Bettina had a table she was building as we spoke. It contained no colours, which made it look more alarming than the Ledger.

We started with the forty-one.

“They’re the delivery promises I found in my records,” Marty said. “Before subtracting the ones completed or replaced.”

“Replaced by what?” Bettina asked.

“In some cases, another promise.”

“Then we need both entries and the agreement connecting them.”

By noon we had matched the entries to nine counterparties. Some deliveries had happened; some promises referred to the same hoped-for Finance capacity; some later promises were offered to settle earlier ones. The total described what had been promised over time, not a stock of permissions awaiting issue.

Bettina drew a line beneath her table. “Let’s take the disputed March group.”

There were six promises in that group. Marty had expected Finance capacity to cover them, though Wole had approved only one specific transfer, which had already been used elsewhere. None of the six had been delivered by its agreed date.

Simon leaned over the table. “I bought three claims from the original holders.”

“Claims against Marty?” I asked.

“Against the delivery arrangements. I paid each holder with a promise of my own to transfer a future slot, subject to the allocation and approvals. They weren’t slots I already had.”

Bettina checked the messages. “Three claims acquired. Marty remained the person expected to deliver those three. Does everyone agree?”

Marty nodded. Simon said, “Yes.”

“The other three?”

“I agreed to take those over,” Simon said. “The counterparties accepted me in Marty’s place.”

Bettina turned her screen. Three signed records named Simon as the replacement obligor and released Marty from those delivery promises.

“That is a novation,” she said. “Simon owes those three under the recorded agreements. Marty does not owe them as the original promisor.”

Marty exhaled.

Bettina opened a separate email. “Except that you later gave these same three counterparties a personal assurance.”

Marty leaned forward. “I said I’d make sure they weren’t left short.”

“You signed it.”

“I thought Simon would deliver.”

“I understand. The question is what you agreed if he didn’t.”

The email said Marty would make good any shortfall if Simon failed to deliver, in terms the four of them would agree later. Bettina read it twice.

“It’s a separate personal guarantee,” she said. “Its effect and the proposed remedy are disputed. It did not put those three delivery promises back in your Finance balance.”

Simon rubbed his forehead. “So I have three claims and three obligations.”

“And Marty has potential exposure on the three you assumed,” Bettina said. “As well as the three claims you acquired from the original holders.”

“Six,” Marty said.

“Three direct promises and a guarantee concerning three others,” she said. “Please don’t add them together as though they’re identical.”

She wrote the distinction at the bottom of the table. Simon watched her type.

“What about the end of March?” I asked. “The slots expired.”

“The permissions did. The delivery dates were missed before expiry.” Bettina closed the email. “Nobody can use an expired Q1 slot for a meeting. That doesn’t decide these disputed agreements.”

Simon scrolled through his records. “I can contact the three people I bought from and confirm the transfers.”

“And the three whose obligations you assumed,” Bettina said.

“I have those messages.”

“Keep them. Don’t negotiate a new settlement without including us and the counterparties.”

Marty’s phone lit up on the table. He turned it over without reading the message.

Bettina looked at him. “Are people asking you to do more work?”

“One person wants help on Friday.”

“Who?”

Marty hesitated.

“You can tell me privately,” she said.

He took the phone and followed her into the corridor. Through the glass I saw him show her the screen. She read it, then asked him something I could not hear.

Simon stayed seated. “I didn’t know what he’d signed until this morning.”

“You knew he hadn’t delivered the claims you bought.”

“Yes.”

“And you bought them anyway.”

He looked at the six rows on Bettina’s screen. “I thought there was a way they could still be worth something.”

When Bettina and Marty returned, she asked me for the names of the relevant managers. Marty agreed that Wole could be told about the Friday request; he wanted to speak to him himself first.

Bettina saved the table as a working reconstruction. It accounted for the six March promises, though it did not settle them. The remaining entries on Marty’s list still needed their own agreements checked.

Marty packed his laptop slowly.

“Can I tell Leanne anything?” he asked.

“Tell her we’re reviewing the records,” Bettina said. “And that we’ll contact her about her particular agreement.”

He nodded. At the door he stopped.

“She did lose the time,” he said. “I don’t want the answer to be that nothing happened.”

Bettina glanced at the table she had made. “Neither do I.”