Chapter 10: The Afternoon Between
I took the inventory folder home and left it on the kitchen table. Every time I passed it, I saw the note beside the shed: Simon has a key.
At lunchtime I made toast and ate half of it standing up. Tom had not sent another message. I checked Lena’s last reply to me, although I knew exactly what was there, then put the phone down before I could write anything else.
The reproduction was in the drawer beneath the television, inside the envelope Lena had sent. I had put it there after taking it to the studio on Friday, because the drawer was dry and the envelope would lie flat. Now I wanted to see the whole photograph again, without looking first at the words underneath.
I cleared a space on the table, moving the inventory folder to a chair. The reproduction showed the family on the lawn: Dad behind the table, Simon beside him, Lena and me on the grass, and Beth at the edge, partly behind a chair. Her cardigan sleeve looked pale. I thought again of the red cardigan I remembered, but I could not be sure of its colour or the day she had worn it.
In the caption beneath us, Beth’s name appeared among the others.
I had looked at that name so often over the last few days that it had begun to seem darker than the rest. I covered it with a piece of blank paper, then moved the paper away.
The photograph had been taken before Beth was hurt. It could not tell me where she went afterward, or why the adults had said she arrived later. I knew those limits. I was less certain why I kept repeating them to myself whenever I looked at her.
In the cupboard beside the television was a shoebox of loose family photographs. I had brought it from Dad’s house after his funeral, intending to sort it with Lena. On top were pictures from a seaside holiday, the corners curled from years without an album. I found one of Ruth Bell holding a towel around Lena’s shoulders outside a cottage. Lena was laughing, her eyes shut against the sun.
The cottage door stood open behind them. I could not remember which holiday it was. The photograph in Dad’s album showed him with Ruth outside a hotel, a key on a ribbon in her hand; I had not been able to place that one either.
There were several photographs from the August gathering. One showed paper plates on the lawn and a jug on its side. Another showed the backs of three adults watching something beyond the frame. None helped me put the afternoon in order.
I turned the second photograph over. Dad had written the date on the back in pencil, with a short line beneath it. The pencil had caught on the paper and left a small dark mark where he began.
I remembered the sound of an ambulance door closing. I remembered Lena beside the kitchen sink, her hands wet, telling me not to get in anyone’s way. Beth had already been taken for treatment when Lena spoke to me. Whether the ambulance door belonged before or after the sink, or even to that day, I could not say.
I thought the scene at Dad’s desk had come afterward, though I could not place it on the same day.
The window was open, just as I had remembered at the studio. There was a ruler on the desk and a strip of cream paper beneath Lena’s hand. She had mixed paste in the chipped white dish. She asked me to hold the strip flat while she measured it, and I complained when she moved the ruler.
“What was it for?” I said aloud.
A car passed outside, its tyres hissing on the wet road.
I had helped Lena make labels before. Dad kept the albums in the study, and Lena sometimes put loose photographs away for him. We might have been making an album neat. I pictured the paste spreading in a thin line, the ruler lifting and coming down again.
I remembered wanting the strip to be straight. I remembered Lena telling me to hurry.
I could have sat with those details longer. Instead, I picked up the photograph of Ruth and Lena and slid it back into the box. The box had been stored on its end, which was why the seaside pictures had curled. I fetched a larger one from the cupboard and began arranging the photographs in small stacks.
It was a useful thing to do. Their edges would be better supported, and I could take them to the studio for suitable enclosures when I had time. I told myself I was doing it because Dad had left too many things in the wrong places.
Halfway through, I found a picture of Lena and me at the desk. We were younger than we had been in 2003. Lena was cutting shapes from paper; I was holding up something that might have been a crooked star. Dad had written Christmas preparations on the back.
I put it beside the reproduction.
The two photographs did not belong to the same day, but together they made the study look like a room where nothing worse than an uneven line could happen. I had been arranging them to make that point.
My phone lit up. For a moment I thought it might be Lena, but the name was Nadia’s.
Can you send me your notes on the caption edge? I’m updating the shared index tomorrow.
I typed, I’ll bring them in.
Then I deleted it.
Are you at the studio today?
She answered that she was there for another hour.
Nadia was at her bench when I arrived, wrapping a set of prints for collection. She held up one hand while she finished folding the enclosure, then turned toward me.
“Any news?”
“No.”
“I’m sorry.” She looked at the notebook under my arm. “You didn’t have to come in.”
“I wanted to check the wording.”
She cleared a corner of the bench. I opened my notebook to the page about the pale edge and the paste. The words looked orderly, with dates in the margin and a line separating observation from memory. I had been pleased with that line when I drew it.
“I remembered something else,” I said.
“About the paper?”
“About the time after Beth was hurt. I think Lena and I were at Dad’s desk sometime afterward. She asked me to help her with a strip. She measured it and I held it flat.”
Nadia took off her glasses and rested them on the bench. “Is that when you remember using the paste?”
“I think so. The window was open. The dish was there.” I pointed to my note. “I hadn’t connected it with that day.”
“What were you making?”
“I don’t know.”
“Do you remember the photograph being there?”
I saw the desk, Lena’s arm across it, the ruler. There was a pale rectangle beyond her hand, but I could not tell whether it belonged to that afternoon or to the photographs I had been studying since.
“I can’t place it,” I said. “It might have been an album label. Lena used to put things away for Dad.”
Nadia nodded, though she did not write anything down.
“I may have handled the mount,” I said. “Or paper intended for it.”
“Then that belongs in the handling history.”
I had expected her to ask more questions. Her answer made me feel abruptly foolish, as though I had brought her a confession and she had mistaken it for a filing problem.
“I said I may have.”
“Yes.”
“There were other things we made at that desk.”
“Put that in too.”
I closed the notebook. “You think it was the caption.”
“I haven’t said that.”
“You want it in the record.”
“Because you think you remember working with a strip of paper that day, and this is something you’re examining. The record can say what you remember and what you don’t. It doesn’t have to decide for you.”
She returned her glasses to her face. One lens had a small smear at the edge; she took them off again and rubbed it with her sleeve.
“I’ve been looking at the writing,” I said. “The visible strip has some of Dad’s forms.”
“Some forms can be shared.”
“I learned to print from him.”
“Then that’s relevant as well. But I can’t tell you who wrote it by looking at a few letters.”
I wanted her to look anyway. I wanted her to lean over the mount and find a feature so clearly Dad’s that the rest of the conversation could be put away. Instead I asked, “Do you have time to open the cabinet?”
“We don’t need the object to amend your notes.”
She was right, and I resented her for making the correction so gently.
At the computer I opened the handling record. I added the present date and began: I think this may have been after the accident. Lena asked me to help with a strip of paper at Daniel’s desk.
I described holding the strip while she measured it, and the paste in the dish. I added that I could not establish whether the strip was associated with this photograph or mount, and that we had used the desk for other paper work.
I read the entry aloud. Nadia asked me to change after the accident to after Beth was taken for treatment, since that was the point by which I thought I placed the memory. I changed it to: I think this may have been after Beth was taken for treatment.
“Is that enough?” I asked.
“It’s what you’ve told me.”
I saved the file. The new entry sat beneath the recent dates, separated from them by twenty-three years. There was no way to make the space between them smaller by choosing better words.
As I shut the notebook, Nadia said, “Mara.”
I waited.
“You can add to it if you remember more.”
I put the notebook in my bag. On the walk home I tried to recall what Lena had said at the desk, but each time I reached the open window and the ruler, I began considering the wording of the record instead. By the time I reached my building, I knew exactly where I would add another sentence. I still had not asked myself what had been written on the strip.