Chapter 6: The Account Everyone Knows
I woke before the alarm and reached for my phone. There were no messages from Lena.
I put the phone down and thought of the calls I still had to make.
The kitchen was cold. I filled the kettle and found yesterday’s list on the counter, Tom’s handwriting crowded around the edge of the school newsletter. York, Bristol, the guesthouse near the coast. I had called the friend in York from the studio. She had not heard from Lena in months, but had promised to pass on the message if she did. I still had the other calls to make.
While the kettle boiled, I took a mug from the cupboard. It had a chip inside the rim. Dad had given it to me when I moved into the flat, along with a saucepan and a set of tea towels he said were too good for him. I turned the chip away before pouring in the water.
Beth had arrived late. That was the part of the story I had always known.
I carried my tea to the table and sat with Tom’s list in front of me. After the lunch, Beth had wandered into the workshop. Some shelving had fallen, and she had been hurt. The adults had found her and taken her for treatment.
I tried to recall who had first told me. I could hear Dad’s voice saying she arrived later, but the words might have come from the caption, read so often that I had supplied his voice for them. Simon had used the same account at some point. I could not place the conversation. There had been family lunches, birthdays, the years when Beth was young enough for adults to discuss her while she was in the room.
I had been thirteen. I remembered the garden table and the grass beneath my legs. I remembered Lena pulling at the hem of her skirt because it had ridden up when she sat down. I remembered being told to move out of the way afterward, though I could not see who had said it or where I had been standing.
Beth’s cardigan came back to me next: red, with small round buttons.
I put down the mug. In the photograph her sleeve looked pale, but the colour in a reproduction could be unreliable. Simon had said her mother bought the cardigan for a wedding. I pictured Beth tugging at one cuff, then wondered whether I was remembering a wedding instead. She could have worn it on more than one occasion. I could not even be sure it was red.
The photograph placed her at the lunch. I had recognized her in it long before Lena sent the copy. I had also repeated that she arrived later, without stopping to ask later than what.
I took a sheet from the pad by the telephone and wrote:
What I remember: Beth at the garden lunch.
Underneath, I wrote:
What I was told: she went into the workshop alone.
The second sentence looked too definite. I crossed out was told and wrote family account above it. I could not yet say which person had told me that part, or when.
My phone lit up on the table. It was an appointment reminder from the dentist. I dismissed it and opened my messages with Beth.
There were birthday wishes and a photograph of a cake she had made for a colleague. I had replied that the icing looked too good to cut. She had sent back a picture of the empty plate. Our last exchange was from August: a thank-you for a card, followed by my promise that we should catch up properly.
I pressed her number before I could decide on a message.
She answered on the fourth ring. There was a low hum behind her and the sound of someone speaking indistinctly.
“Mara?”
“Hi. Is this a bad time?”
“I’ve got a few minutes.” A door closed, muffling the voices. “What’s happened?”
I looked at the list. “Lena hasn’t been in touch since Thursday. Tom and I have reported her missing.”
The hum continued for a second before Beth spoke.
“Missing as in nobody knows where she is?”
“Yes. She asked Tom to keep Finn for a couple of extra nights, but she missed a call she’d promised him. She was supposed to meet me that evening and didn’t come.”
“When did you report it?”
“Thursday night.”
“And you’re calling me now?”
“I should have called sooner.”
“Has Tom heard anything?”
“No. I spoke to him yesterday.” I hesitated. “Have you heard from her?”
“Yes.”
I sat up. “When?”
“Last week. She called me on Tuesday.”
“Did she say where she was going?”
“No. She called my mobile, then reception put her through to me at work when I didn’t answer. I think she was at home: Finn came in while we were talking and asked her where his football shirt was.”
The ordinary detail made me see Lena in her kitchen, phone held against her shoulder while she searched the washing basket. I did not know whether that was what had happened.
“What did she want?” I asked.
“She wanted to meet. I couldn’t that day.”
“Did she sound frightened?”
“She sounded like Lena when she wants something.”
“Beth—”
“I don’t mean that as a criticism. She was persistent. She said it mattered.”
“Did she mention Simon?”
“No.”
“Or Dad’s house?”
“She mentioned a photograph.” Beth paused. “Have the police got her number?”
“I don’t know whether we gave it to them. Tom found a recent photograph of her, and they told him how to provide it. They asked us to let them know if we heard anything else.”
“All right. I’ll tell them about the call.”
“I can pass it on.”
“I said I’ll tell them.”
I gave her the reference number from the envelope on my counter. She repeated it back while I checked each digit. Her voice had become brisk, as if she had taken a pen and paper out at her end.
“Did she say anything about an argument?” I asked.
“No.”
“Tom said she’d had one, but she didn’t tell him with whom.”
“Do you think it was about Daniel?”
“I don’t know. Simon said Lena had been to see him a few days ago. He said she was upset.”
Beth made a small sound. I waited for her to explain it.
“What did he tell you?” she asked.
“That she’d shown him a photograph on her phone. He said she was mistaken about my father changing a caption.”
“And you spoke to him before you spoke to me.”
“He came to Daniel’s house yesterday. I was looking for the album.”
“Of course he did.”
I wanted to ask what she meant. Instead I said, “Lena sent me a copy of the photograph. She wanted me to bring it when we met.”
“The garden one?”
“Yes. You’re in it.”
“I know.”
“There are different captions. The one in Dad’s album says you arrived later.”
“I was already there.”
She said it plainly. I looked down at the sentence on my pad, my pencil mark pressing through the paper.
“I can see you in the photograph,” I said. “I don’t know why the caption says otherwise.”
“Neither do I.”
“Do you remember the lunch?”
“Bits of it.”
“I thought you might remember the cardigan. Simon said you hated it.”
Beth was silent long enough that I thought the call had failed.
“You’ve spoken to him about my clothes?”
“He recognized it in the picture. I’m sorry. I was trying to work out what I remembered.”
“Why?”
The question was not hostile, but it made me aware of my pad, the crossed-out words, the way I had arranged the morning around a photograph of her.
“Because I’ve been repeating the story about the accident for years,” I said. “I’m beginning to think I accepted parts of it without knowing where they came from.”
“You did.”
“I wanted to ask you what you remember.”
“No.”
I gripped the edge of the table. “I’m not asking you to explain everything. Lena wanted to talk about the photograph, and I’m trying to understand why.”
“And I’m telling you I don’t want to discuss the accident with you.”
“I’m worried about her.”
“So am I. You could have called to tell me she was missing without asking me to go through it.”
I looked at the birthday messages still open on my phone. The cake had been bright yellow, with uneven blue lettering across the top. I had forgotten that until I saw it again.
“You’re right,” I said.
Beth exhaled. “I have to get back. I’m covering the desk while someone’s at lunch.”
“Will you tell me if she calls?”
“Yes. Tell her Finn needs her, if you hear first.”
“I will.”
She did not end the call immediately. Somewhere behind her, a telephone rang twice.
“Mara,” she said, “I was there before the photograph. I remember that. But please don’t ring me again today to ask about the workshop.”
“All right.”
The call ended. I remained at the table, looking at the crossed-out line. I had expected Beth’s answer to settle something. It had settled one thing: she remembered being at the lunch before the picture was taken. It had not told me where she went afterward, and she had made it clear she did not want to be questioned about that.
I wrote the date and time of the call at the top of the page. Beneath my earlier notes I added: Beth says Lena called Tuesday of the previous week. She will contact police herself. She says she was at the gathering before the photograph.
Then I called the former colleague in Bristol. He had not seen Lena. He took my number and promised to pass on Tom’s message if she contacted him. The guesthouse number went to voicemail, where I left my name and asked for a call back.
When I returned to the table, Beth had sent a text.
Please let me know when there is news of Lena.
I replied that I would. I did not add a question.