Chapter 10 of 35

AI-generated book by Nora WestleyBook rights and permissions

Chapter 7: A Picture with People In It

On Thursday morning, Mara arrived at Nell Harwood’s house with a paper bag of tomatoes and the uncomfortable feeling that she had misunderstood her instructions.

Nell opened the door before she could knock a second time.

“I said you could come empty-handed.”

“They’re from my neighbor. She brought me rather more than I can eat.”

“In that case, I accept them on behalf of your neighbor’s tomato plants. Come in.”

Mara followed her through a narrow hall. A basket stood beside the stairs, filled with runner beans.

Nell noticed her looking. “I picked those on Monday for June. I gave half to Imogen yesterday, but there are still enough to feed a committee.”

“We could put them in Peter’s meeting room. He has biscuits.”

“He’ll need something stronger than beans if he’s going to persuade everyone about that path.”

Nell led her into the sitting room, where an open photograph album occupied most of a small table. A tin of biscuits stood beside it, its lid tilted by the quantity inside.

“I’ve made tea,” Nell said. “And before you ask, yes, I know the bench is in one of these photographs. I did not invite you here to turn my brother into an inventory entry.”

“I wouldn’t want to.”

“Good. His name was Arthur, and he disliked being numbered. The hospital tried it once and heard about it for the rest of the week.”

Mara set her notebook on her knee without opening it. Nell poured tea into cups with a blue border, then offered the biscuit tin. Mara chose one from the top, causing three others to shift.

“Take another,” Nell said. “It’s a controlled collapse.”

For a few minutes they spoke about Arthur. He had worked at the station before the passenger service stopped, and afterward had continued to wind the clock in the garden shelter until someone persuaded the council to replace its mechanism. He had grown beans as well, though according to Nell he planted them too close together and denied it every year.

“June took his side,” Nell said. “She said a crowded bean was a happy bean. She knew perfectly well she was provoking me.”

Mara smiled. “Did she grow hers differently?”

“Of course. June was very particular about her own garden. Other people’s gardens were where she experimented.”

Nell turned a page. The plastic cover crackled under her fingers.

“She came here last autumn with a bag of bulbs and announced that the strip by my gate needed cheering up. I told her the strip was mine and perfectly cheerful. She planted them while I made tea.”

“Did you mind?”

“I minded being told what my garden needed. The daffodils were excellent.”

Nell’s hand rested on the page for a moment. “She was meant to collect those beans today. I keep thinking I should put the kettle on before she arrives.”

The room was quiet. Mara looked at the basket visible through the open doorway.

“You told me on Monday,” she said.

“She would have brought something to trade. Seeds, probably, or a complaint about the council.” Nell gave a short breath that might have become a laugh. “Sometimes both in the same envelope.”

She turned another page and tapped a photograph.

“There. That’s Arthur.”

He sat near the end of a wooden bench, holding a paper cup. A little girl stood beside him with an expression of grave concentration, apparently trying to balance a cake on a plate. Behind them, a painted clock was fixed to the station shelter, and a banner hung between two posts.

Mara leaned closer. The bench stood on gravel. Beyond its left end she could see the shelter’s familiar green door.

“Was this in the station garden?” she asked.

“Yes. That’s my great-niece Polly with the cake. She dropped it a moment later and blamed Arthur for distracting her.”

“What did he do?”

“Ate it anyway. He said the gravel gave it character.”

The lettering on the banner read STATION GARDEN OPEN DAY. A smaller line was partly hidden by a cluster of paper flowers.

Nell touched the album caption. “That was the September open day, six years ago. I remember because Arthur won a jar of marmalade in the raffle and gave it to June. She brought the empty jar back with a note asking for a refill.”

The caption beneath the photograph gave the same date: September 14, six years ago.

Mara took her notebook out. “May I write that down?”

“Certainly.”

She copied the caption and described the clock, banner and green door. “Do you remember writing the date at the time?”

Nell considered it. “I wrote the captions when I put the album together. That may have been later.”

“How much later?”

“I don’t know. A year or two, perhaps. I had a box of photographs and a very determined afternoon.” Nell gave her a level look. “I was there, Mara. I’m not inventing the marmalade.”

“I believe you. I’m trying to separate what the picture shows from what we can establish about its date.”

“Yes, I can hear June in that sentence.” Nell reached for her tea. “I remember the open day. I’m less certain whether I remembered the date or copied it from something when I made the album.”

Mara wrote that too and turned the notebook toward her. Nell read it, then nodded.

“Could I photograph the picture and the caption?” Mara asked. “And give the details to Inspector Shah?”

“You may. I’d rather the photograph stayed here, though.”

“Of course.”

Mara used her phone, taking one image of the whole page and another closer view of the photograph. Nell insisted on checking that Arthur’s face was visible.

“He looks cross,” Mara said.

“He was squinting. There’s a difference.”

The photograph showed the bench in the garden, but the caption alone did not settle when. June had found a transfer notation whose timing and meaning she could not establish. Mara had no copy of that notation in front of her, and the photograph could not explain it by itself.

Nell closed the album gently. “Will it help?”

“I hope so. I can look for a program or a newspaper account of the open day. That might help establish the date.”

“And then?”

“I’ll pass the sources on. The police may already know more about the records than I do.”

Nell pushed the biscuit tin toward her again. “Take one for the search. The library’s very good, but I doubt they provide refreshments.”


At the library, Mara found Theo at the returns desk holding a narrow ledger and a book with a dark cloth cover.

“I was about to come to your workshop,” she said.

“I was coming to you. I need a reference book from upstairs, and I thought I’d save you the walk.”

The librarian directed them to a table near the local-history shelves. Theo set down the books and opened the ledger.

“Public sign repairs,” he said. “The old book is mostly orders, but there are a few locations in it.”

Mara explained about Nell’s photograph and the open-day banner. Theo turned several pages with a paint-stained finger.

“I repainted the station clock lettering,” he said. “But that was after the clock mechanism was replaced. Let me see.”

He found the entry. It gave a date two years after the one in Nell’s caption.

“So it won’t date the photograph,” Mara said.

“Afraid not. I can tell you the lettering was badly in need of attention.”

“That may be useful to someone writing a history of the lettering.”

“I’ll wait for the commission.” He slid the older book toward her. “You’re welcome to look through this while I find mine upstairs. I do need it back before closing.”

Mara checked the station-related entries, noting the dates and wording but finding nothing that fixed the open day. When Theo returned, he helped her put the books aside and carried his reference book to the desk.

“Any luck?” he asked.

“Only with the lettering.”

“Better than nothing.”

“Marginally.”

He glanced at her notebook. “June used to say a map ought to have people in it, even if you couldn’t draw them all.”

“She said that to you?”

“When I suggested putting a neat border around a route sign. She wanted room for the market stalls, which weren’t there every day.” He adjusted the books under his arm. “We argued about it for a week.”

“Who won?”

“The market stalls. I made the border thinner.”

After he left, Mara asked the librarian, Ruth, about the station garden open day. Ruth led her to a drawer of local-event programs and showed her how they were arranged.

“Not all of them are here,” she said. “People brought them in when they remembered. Sometimes after finding them in a cookbook.”

“Is that an official filing category?”

“It should be.”

They found a program dated September 14, six years earlier. Its cover announced the station garden open day and listed a seed stall, a children’s cake competition and a raffle. Inside was a small reproduction of the event banner, including the paper flowers and the partly obscured line: GARDENS FOR EVERYONE.

“It looks right,” Mara said.

Ruth drew out a local-history folder containing photographs donated to the library. One showed the banner hanging between the station-garden posts, with the green shelter door behind it. A note identified it as the same open day and named its donor. Mara compared the paper flowers in that image with those in Nell’s photograph: one on the right-hand cluster had a bent outer petal.

The program gave the occasion its date; the library image connected that occasion’s banner to the station garden. Nell’s photograph showed Arthur and the bench beneath the same banner, with the clock and shelter behind them.

Ruth allowed Mara to photograph the program cover, the banner illustration, the library photograph and its identifying note. Mara wrote down the folder and collection details so that someone else could find the sources.

She checked the time, then called Leila from outside the library.

“Nell showed me a photograph of her brother on the station-garden bench,” she said. “Her album caption dates it to September 14, six years ago. She remembers the event, but she isn’t sure whether she knew the date independently when she wrote the caption.”

Leila listened while Mara described the program and the library photograph.

“Can you send the images and the source details?” she asked.

“Yes. I have Nell’s permission to share the photograph, and Ruth showed me where the library materials are kept.”

“Thank you. We can check them against the records.”

“June had mentioned a transfer notation, but I don’t know what date it gives or precisely what it means.”

“That’s useful to keep separate,” Leila said. “Please send what you have.”

Mara went back inside, chose the clearest images and sent them with a short account of who had supplied each item. She included Nell’s uncertainty about the caption and the details of the library collection. The photograph might help establish where the bench had been on that September day; any contradiction with an inventory entry still needed checking. A transfer could also have been recorded incorrectly without anyone intending harm.

When she finished, Ruth came over with a small envelope.

“Nell called,” she said. “She wanted to know whether you’d remembered the biscuit.”

Mara took it from her coat pocket, slightly broken but otherwise intact.

“I have.”

“Good. She said I was to make sure you ate it before you got involved in anything else.”

Mara sat at the table and obeyed. On her notebook page, beneath the photograph details, she wrote Arthur Harwood, Polly, open day, marmalade. Those things would not resolve a transfer notation. They belonged with the picture all the same.