Chapter 18 of 35

AI-generated book by Nora WestleyBook rights and permissions

Chapter 15: The Second Recovery

On Friday morning, Mara was halfway through drawing a key for her map when Gus telephoned.

“They’ve found the station bench,” he said.

Her pencil stopped above the page. “Where?”

“At the workshop. The officers found it yesterday, behind some timber. They’ve finished looking at it, and Nell’s coming to see it this morning.” He hesitated. “I thought you’d want to know.”

“I would. Thank you.”

“Don’t thank me yet. Nell asked whether I’d help her carry a cake, and I suspect that means there’s a conversation attached.”

“Should I come and protect you?”

“You can try. Bring a large plate.”

By the time Mara reached the workshop yard, Nell was standing beside a car with a cake tin on its roof. Gus held the lid while she lifted out a square sponge covered in pink icing.

“It’s for the volunteers,” Nell said when she saw Mara. “I made it before Gus called. I’m not rewarding anyone for losing a bench.”

“Of course not,” Mara said.

“And I haven’t made enough for seconds.”

Gus glanced at the size of the cake. “That ought to keep us going until Tuesday.”

Nell gave him the look Mara remembered from school, when Nell had worked in the office and could silence a corridor with a raised eyebrow. Gus found a plate and began cutting.

The station bench stood beneath the yard’s shallow awning, clear of the door. Mara recognized its curved back and the small carved leaves at either end from Nell’s photograph. Someone had sanded part of one arm, leaving pale wood exposed. A tin of paint and a brush lay on a nearby worktable.

Nell approached slowly. She put her handbag on the ground, then rested her hand on the back of the bench.

“There’s the mark Arthur made,” she said.

Mara came closer. A shallow nick crossed one slat.

“He dropped a flowerpot on it at the open day. He said the pot jumped.”

“Was it empty?” Gus asked.

“Unfortunately not. We found soil in his turn-ups for a week.”

Nell smiled, but only briefly. She bent to examine the sanded arm.

“Why wasn’t I told it was here?”

Gus set down the knife. “I didn’t know it had arrived. I helped load it, and Evan said he was bringing it to the workshop. I told you that.”

“I know you did.” Nell straightened. “I mean why didn’t Evan tell me? He knows whose bench it is.”

A voice from the gate said, “I should have done.”

Evan Rook came into the yard carrying a folded dustsheet. He looked at the bench before he looked at Nell.

“I meant to return it after the repainting,” he said. “Then the workshop got busy, and I didn’t get back to it.”

“For three weeks?”

“Something like that. I can check the date.”

Nell folded her arms. “You could have left me a note.”

“Yes.” Evan put the dustsheet on the worktable. “I should have done that too.”

Mara thought of the conversation by the shed. “When I asked you about the station bench, you told me the inventory said it had been transferred years ago.”

“I said the entry recorded an old move,” Evan replied. “The date could have been wrong. The records are a muddle. They have been for years.”

“But you knew you’d taken the bench recently,” Nell said. “Why didn’t you tell me?”

Evan rubbed a thumb along the edge of the dustsheet. “I should have done. I thought I’d get the work finished and have it back before anyone needed to worry.”

“I was already worried. Polly asked me where it had gone.”

For a moment only the station clock could be heard, striking the quarter hour beyond the yard wall.

“I’m sorry,” Evan said.

Nell took a breath. “Was there something wrong with it?”

“The finish was peeling. I wanted to check the joints as well.”

Gus examined the exposed patch without touching it. “There’s sanding been done. I’d want a proper look at the joints before anyone sits on it.”

Mara studied the bench. The sanded arm and paint tin made a repainting attempt plausible. They did not show when the work had begun, or who had done it. Gus had seen the bench loaded, and now it was at the destination Evan had named, but Gus had not seen it arrive.

She took out her notebook. “May I write down what you’ve said?”

Evan nodded. Nell gave a small, impatient wave.

Mara noted the bench’s location, its partly sanded arm and the paint on the table. She attributed the comments about its condition to Gus and Evan. Then she recorded Evan’s account of intending to return it and his apology to Nell.

Gus handed Nell a plate. “You’ll need a fork.”

“I brought some.”

“Of course you did.”

He opened the tin she indicated and found the forks wrapped in a napkin. Nell took one, though she left the cake untouched.

“Arthur used to sit here on market mornings,” she said. “At the station garden, I mean. He’d tell people he was waiting for a train, and they’d tell him there hadn’t been one for years.”

“What did he say to that?” Mara asked.

“He said that explained the delay.”

This time Nell’s smile stayed a little longer. She broke off a corner of cake and ate it.

Evan picked up the dustsheet. “I’ll leave this here until the officers say what can be done next.”

“Is it going back to the garden?” Nell asked.

“I hope so. It needs checking first.”

“Then I want to know when that happens.”

“I’ll make sure you’re told.”

Nell considered him, then set her plate on the worktable. “I would appreciate that.”

Mara stepped away to call Leila. She described what she had seen and repeated Evan’s explanation, making clear that the bench’s condition could not date the work. Leila thanked her and said officers had documented the bench at the workshop. Mara did not ask what else they had found.

When she returned, Gus was persuading Nell to take a second piece of cake home.

“I said no seconds for the volunteers,” Nell told him. “I’m not a volunteer.”

“A distinction Arthur would have admired.”

“He would have taken the whole tin.”


Nell invited Mara back to her garden for tea. “I’ve got runner beans that need picking,” she said. “You can hold the basket and tell me whether I’m being unreasonable.”

The garden lay behind Nell’s house, sheltered by a brick wall that held the morning’s warmth. Bean vines climbed a row of canes, their leaves beginning to yellow at the edges. Nell handed Mara a basket and inspected the plants with the seriousness of a jeweler.

“Am I?” she asked.

“Being unreasonable?”

“Yes.”

“I think you’re entitled to be upset that no one told you where the bench was.”

Nell snapped a bean from its stem. “It’s public property. I know that. I don’t expect to be consulted every time someone tightens a screw.”

“You would have liked to know it had been removed.”

“I would. Arthur’s grandchildren visit it when they come to town.” She dropped the bean into the basket. “Polly asked me about it last month, and I told her I’d find out.”

Mara held the basket closer while Nell reached for another. A bee nosed among the last flowers at the end of the row.

“June asked me about the photograph,” Nell said. “Some weeks before the meeting. I’d forgotten until I saw the bench today.”

“The one with Arthur and Polly?”

“That one. She wanted to know when it was taken.”

“Did she say why?”

“She said she was checking dates for the inventory. I fetched the album, and she wrote something down.” Nell frowned at a bean that had grown around its cane. “I told her the date in the caption. I wish I’d told her I wasn’t certain how I knew it.”

“You told me when we looked at it.”

“After you asked.” Nell eased the bean free. “June didn’t ask whether I remembered the day or the caption. I don’t know that it would have occurred to me to explain.”

Mara could picture June at Nell’s table, pencil ready, listening to a friend who had always sounded sure of her dates.

“She wanted to know whether I had other photographs of the bench,” Nell continued. “I looked, but I couldn’t find one that helped. She was worried about getting something wrong.”

Mara thought of June’s question mark beside the orchard entry. “She told me not to hurry the site checks.”

“She could be patient with other people. She wasn’t always patient with herself.”

They carried the beans to the little table by the back door. Nell went inside for tea and returned with two cups and a plate of plain biscuits.

“I nearly put the cake in front of you again,” she said. “I thought you might be too polite to refuse.”

“I might have been.”

“Then it’s a good thing I saved you.”

Mara sat while Nell poured. Through the open gate she could see a strip of pavement and the top of a hedge across the lane.

“I keep thinking about that evening,” Nell said. “If I’d known June was still in the bandstand…”

Mara set down her cup, giving Nell time to continue.

“I passed the green on my way to an errand. The bandstand door was closed. I thought it was locked already, but I didn’t try it.” Nell turned her cup by its handle. “Then I saw Evan later, near the green, and assumed he’d finished his round.”

She looked toward the gate. “I’ve been trying to remember his keys. I think I saw them, but perhaps I only heard them. He usually has that ring on his belt, and I don’t know whether I’m remembering that instead.”

Mara left the silence for Nell to fill if she wished. Nell took a sip of tea and set her cup down.

“I was in a hurry. I can see the shut door quite plainly, but I’m not sure about the keys.” She gave a short, unhappy laugh. “There. Another thing I should have said at the time.”

“You can tell Leila you’re uncertain,” Mara said. “She’ll want to hear it from you.”

“I will. I don’t want her taking my word for something I can’t remember properly.”

With Nell’s agreement, Mara wrote down what she had offered and read it back. Nell corrected one phrase: she had thought the door was locked; she had not tried it.

“That matters,” Nell said.

Mara changed the note. “I’ll let Leila know what you’ve told me, too.”

“Please do. I’ll call her myself after I’ve had a little time to think.”

Mara put her pencil away. Nell looked into the basket.

“There are enough beans for you to take some.”

“I’d like that.”

“June was supposed to collect a bag. I kept putting it aside, though of course…” She stopped and reached for her tea.

Mara left the basket where it was. After a moment Nell chose a handful of beans and wrapped them in a paper bag for her.

At home, Mara called Leila. She passed on Nell’s account of June’s earlier visit to see the photograph, including Nell’s uncertainty about the source of its caption date. She then read back what she had written about the bandstand: Nell remembered the shut door, had not tried it, and was unsure whether she had seen or heard Evan’s keys. Nell intended to call Leila herself.

“Thank you,” Leila said. “We’ll speak to her.”

Mara added the station bench to her fresh notes: Located at workshop; safety check needed. The heron bench had also been recovered. She looked at the third open circle on her draft, beside the orchard path, and left it unfilled.