Chapter 16 of 35

AI-generated book by Adrian ColeBook rights and permissions

Chapter 13: Beth’s Conditions

Beth called while I was unpacking my bag. I had taken out the cream offcuts and was deciding where to put the school notebook when her name appeared on the screen.

“Did Lena call you?” I asked.

“No. I got your message.”

I had sent it that morning after leaving the cottage photograph on the kitchen table. I had asked whether we could meet, adding that I had no news of Lena. Beth had not replied until now.

“I can do half an hour tomorrow,” she said.

“Could we do today?”

A pause. I heard a door close at her end, then voices at a distance.

“I’m at work, Mara.”

“Sorry. I thought—”

“There’s a café downstairs. I can come down at four, if you’re here by then. I have to be back upstairs at half past.”

I looked at the clock. It was just after three.

“I can make it.”

“And please don’t call my office.”

“I haven’t called your office.”

“I know. Lena did, the Tuesday the week before she was supposed to meet you. She asked reception to put her through when I hadn’t answered my mobile.” Beth lowered her voice. “That was the call I told you about. They were kind about it, but my manager asked if everything was all right. I’d rather not have that conversation again.”

“I won’t call them.”

“Bring yourself. Not a folder.”

Before I could ask what she meant, she ended the call.

I put the notebook on the shelf beside the blue box of schoolbooks. The offcuts stayed in their packet. I had intended to find a larger enclosure for them, but I was already calculating the drive to Beth’s town and where I might park.

At the door I went back for my phone charger. Then I checked that the reproduction was still in the drawer beneath the television. I did not take it out.


Beth was already at a table when I reached the café. She had a paper cup and a sandwich in its wrapper. Her coat was draped over the chair beside her, keeping it from anyone else.

She moved it when she saw me.

“I wasn’t sure you’d find parking,” she said.

“I nearly didn’t.”

“There’s a multistorey behind the library. You have to come in from the other road.”

“I’ll remember.”

She looked at the empty space between us. “No folder. Thank you.”

“I wasn’t going to bring one.”

“You were thinking about it.”

I took off my coat. “Yes.”

Beth pushed the unopened sandwich aside and checked her watch. She wore a navy jumper with a small pale mark near one cuff. I remembered her at ten in a cardigan whose colour I still could not place. The mark on the jumper was probably flour or paint or something from her lunch. I made myself stop trying to give it a history.

“Do you want anything?” she asked.

“I’ll get a coffee.”

“You’ll lose five minutes in the queue.”

“I don’t mind.”

“I do. I’ve got a meeting.”

I sat down again.

Beth took a bite of her sandwich and chewed while I waited. She had always eaten slowly. At family lunches Dad used to offer her the last potato while she was still halfway through her plate, and Simon would say she could never make up her mind. She would keep eating without answering either of them.

“Have you heard anything from Tom?” she asked.

“No. I spoke to him this morning. Finn’s with him.”

“I know Finn’s with him. Is he all right?”

“He’s worried. Tom’s trying to keep things ordinary for him.”

Beth nodded and took another bite.

“I called because I thought you might have heard from Lena,” I said.

“You’ve already asked me that.”

“I know. I wondered if she’d found a way to contact you since we spoke.”

“She hasn’t.”

Her phone lay face down by her cup. I kept looking at it, as if it might light up and relieve both of us of the need to continue.

“I also wanted to talk about the photograph,” I said.

“Of course you did.”

“I’m trying to understand why she sent it.”

“And I’m trying to eat something before a meeting.”

“I’m sorry.”

“You keep saying that very quickly.” She put down the sandwich. “I agreed to see you because I don’t want you deciding my silence means you can ask other people about me.”

“I haven’t.”

“You asked me about Lena. You asked about the day I was hurt. Now you want to ask about a photograph. It’s all the same conversation, as far as I can tell.”

I wanted to distinguish the questions. The photograph was an object; Lena was missing; Beth had told me herself that she had been at the gathering. Each point seemed reasonable until I tried to say it aloud.

“I won’t record you,” I said instead.

Beth’s eyes narrowed. “Were you going to?”

“No.”

“Your phone’s on the table.”

I picked it up. The screen showed no call in progress, no recording. I could have turned it toward her. Instead I put it in my bag.

“All right,” she said. “No recording. And that includes anything I say while we’re walking.”

“All right.”

“And don’t promise me that anything I say stays between us. You can’t promise that for Lena or Simon or anyone else.”

“I can tell you what I intend to do.”

“You can ask me first.”

I nodded. She watched me for a moment longer, then wrapped the rest of her sandwich.

“Lena asked what I remembered,” she said. “When she called that Tuesday, she wanted to meet, but I couldn’t. She came to my flat a few days before she went away.”

“Did she tell you about Simon?”

“She said she’d spoken to him. She was upset, but she wouldn’t tell me everything he’d said.” Beth folded the wrapper into a small square. “She wanted to know if I remembered being on the lawn before the picture was taken.”

“And you told her you were.”

“Yes. I told you that too.”

“I know. Did she say why she was asking?”

“She said your father had changed what the caption said. She had a copy with my name on it.”

My hand moved toward my bag. Beth saw it.

“I didn’t bring it,” I said.

“I’m glad.”

“I’ve been looking at the original. There may be another layer of paper beneath the caption, but Nadia and I can’t tell yet. I thought Dad might have—”

“Mara.”

I stopped.

“Lena wanted me to look at her copy and tell her what I remembered. I asked what she intended to do with it. She said she hadn’t decided.”

“She may have been trying to work that out.”

“That’s what she said.” Beth picked up her cup, found it empty and put it down again. “I told her I wasn’t going to help her start something if she couldn’t tell me where she meant to take it.”

“You thought she wanted to go to the police?”

“I didn’t know. She wouldn’t say. Perhaps she didn’t know either.” Beth glanced toward the counter, where two people in lanyards were waiting for drinks. “She said she was doing it for me. I asked her what that meant. She got angry.”

“Lena gets angry when she’s frightened.”

“Does she?”

“I think so.”

Beth drew her coat onto her lap. “You see how quickly you can explain her to me? She’s the one who came to my flat and asked me to remember something I hadn’t offered to discuss. When I said no, she told me I didn’t understand what was at stake.”

I had said much the same thing to myself about Beth after our call: she did not understand what Lena’s disappearance might mean. I had not considered that she might understand Lena’s manner perfectly and object to it.

“What did you say to her?” I asked.

“That she could leave.” Beth stood, easing her coat on without using the back of the chair. “I was late for an appointment because we’d been talking in the doorway. I had to change it, and I got charged.”

“I’m sorry.”

This time she did not look at me. “I know you are.”


Outside, Beth checked her phone. The sky had cleared, leaving the pavements dark and the air sharp. People came through the office doors behind us, turning their collars up as they went.

“I can walk you to the station,” I said.

“I’m going back upstairs.”

I looked at her.

“The meeting’s on a call. I booked a room because the office is noisy.” She hesitated. “I’ve got five minutes first. I need to get something from the chemist.”

We crossed at the lights and walked along the parade of shops. Beth kept to my left. She shortened her stride at the kerb and waited until the cars had stopped completely before stepping down. I had seen her do it before without thinking to ask whether the movement hurt.

She noticed me noticing.

“My ankle’s stiff when I’ve been sitting,” she said. “I know how to cross a road.”

“I wasn’t going to offer my arm.”

“You looked as if you were deciding.”

She was right. I put my hands in my coat pockets.

After a few steps she said, “People used to tell me that story as though I’d been there for it.”

“The story about the workshop?”

“The one where I arrived late and went in by myself.” She slowed beside a shop window displaying winter scarves. “At Christmas, at birthdays. It would come up if someone mentioned my ankle, and Simon would say I’d always been determined to explore. Your father would say it was a terrible bit of bad luck.”

I had heard versions of it at those meals. I remembered Simon smiling as he spoke, and Dad reaching for a serving spoon. I had been old enough to hear the distinction between a story offered to Beth and one offered about her. I had not made it.

“Did you tell them they were wrong?” I asked.

Beth turned to me. “Do you remember what happened when I did?”

I searched for a particular meal, a particular objection. There were too many tables in my memory, too many people talking at once.

“No.”

“They corrected me. Sometimes they’d say I was too young to remember properly. Sometimes they’d change the subject before I’d finished.” She pulled her sleeve over the pale mark on her cuff. “After a while I stopped bringing it up at lunch. That isn’t the same as agreeing.”

We reached the chemist. Beth went inside for a prescription while I waited near the door. She came back with a small paper bag and checked the label before putting it away.

“Lena thinks I’ve been waiting for someone to prove it,” she said. “Maybe you do too.”

“I thought the photograph might help.”

“With what?”

I looked past her at the crossing. “It shows you were there.”

“I know I was there.”

I could not offer the photograph as a gift after that.

Beth tucked the paper bag into her handbag. “If Lena turns up, tell me. I want to know she’s safe.”

“I will.”

“But don’t send me pictures of things, or notes you’ve made, unless you ask first. I don’t want them arriving while I’m at work.”

“All right.”

“And if she wants to speak to me, she can ask. You don’t need to arrange it for her.”

I agreed. She checked the time again and began walking back toward the office. At the crossing she pressed the button herself. I stood beside her until the green figure appeared, then let her set the pace.

On the other side she said, “I haven’t decided what I want to do about any of it.”

“You don’t have to decide now.”

“I know.”

She went through the office doors without looking back. I watched until she had reached the lift, then turned toward the car park.

My phone had no new messages. At the top of my recent calls was Beth’s number; beneath it was Ruth’s. I considered calling Tom to tell him what Beth had said, then closed the screen. Beth had told me Lena asked about the gathering and that she had refused to join an investigation without knowing its purpose. She had not given me the rest to distribute.

At the car I sent Tom a message: Beth hasn’t heard from Lena. She wants to know when we do.

He replied almost immediately. I’ll tell you as soon as there’s anything.

I sat with the engine off for a minute. At home, the notebook from Dad’s house was on the shelf beside the blue box. I could turn to the geography notes and compare the writing with the caption on my phone. I would have to decide whether to do that when I got there.

I started the car.